procycling Blog

All blogs

Subscribe stuff

Why we won't fire Frankie Andreu

Daniel Friebe, Procycling Features editor Thursday, Nov 1, 2007 12.47pm

Here's a little tip for your readers: if you're ever working on a bike magazine, and you want to increase levels of reader feedback, employ a confessed former drug cheat to test and review bikes for you. You might get criticised, vilified, accused of naivety or scorned but, hey, any feedback is good feedback, right?

Actually that's more or less how we look at it here. Every one of our readers is entitled to their own opinion, and free to switch their allegiance to a rival publication if they see fit. Some, on learning that we had signed up ex-US Postal rider and confessed EPO-user Frankie Andreu to our team of bike testers, may already have done so. Others might follow when they've finished reading this blog...

You see, we understand everyone who writes in telling us to stop endorsing former cheats, but we also think the question is more complex than that. In our view there are three categories of, well - we might as well be blunt - dope cheat: there are the guys who spent years juicing to earn a pretty penny and still deny it today; there's another category of rider who has been dragged kicking and screaming into the confession booth, resenting every second; and there's a third category who bowed only to pressure from their own conscience, and who usually go on to become outspoken critics of doping. We'll leave to you to find a slot for the Bassos, Landises, Hamiltons and Herases of this world, but we can tell you that Frankie Andreu fits very much into the third category.

Why is this important? A cheat's still a cheat, isn't it? Well, yes, but it seems to us absolutely churlish and naïve to deny that, for a period of several years in professional cycling, EPO abuse was very much the norm. Frankie Andreu was a child of that tainted generation, yes, but he also has the experience, self-knowledge and maturity to become a force for good in the sport. Another former EPO user, David Millar is a living, breathing, pedalling example of how that can be achieved.

Frankie won't change the world testing bikes for Procycling, but let it be known that we hired him not only because he knows a sprocket from a seat-tube, but also because we wanted to express our solidarity with a guy who had the wherewithal to release a large skeleton from his own and the sport's overcrowded closet. The same honesty had already cost him at least one job, condemnation from his former team leader and team boss, several friends, not to mention a good number of sleepless nights. All for what? Because he cheated or because he had the audacity to put a fist through a very old, very thick wall of silence?

So, no, if you're waiting for us to fire Frankie, don't hold your breath. As you'll discover if you read his review of Specialized's S-Works Roubaix SL in this month's mag, he knows what he's doing and he can write. He even gets his copy in on time. Our hunch from spending time with Frankie is that he's also a good guy. Yes, believe it or not, they sometimes make mistakes too...

The rest of our November issue should prove less contentious, but that doesn't mean you won't be glued to the pages like every other month. My own highlight is the latest instalment of the adventures of Kevin "The Hulse" Hulsmans on page 26, but then that's my favourite bit every month. Please, readers, tell me that I'm not alone.

User Comments

There are 7 comments on this post

Showing 1 - 7 of 7 comments

  • Can't believe what a hypocritical and arrogant defence that is. So PROCYCLING is saying it's ok for the Cycling community to show zero tolerance to doping, but PROCYCLING will set there own moral agenda on magazine sales and ex-pro (albeit a cheat) going cheap to provide the bike reviews. You patronise your readers and take our veiws for granted. Well I hope you can afford to be as two faced when sales dwindle. Why don't you get Frankie Andreu to write a review on EPO -v- Testosterone for performance, taste and cost, afterall he is qualified, being an ex-pro cyclist.

  • Moral agenda! It's just a bike mate you want to calm down a bit.

    It's actually a pretty good review. But then I'm not surprised. I've got plenty of mates who take drugs and ride bikes and they certainly know their stuff when it comes to kit.

    I also think your idea of an EPO v Testosterone would make and excellent test.

  • Hey PhilHays, are you sure your real name isn't Mr Lance Armstrong???????

    I've got no time for dopers, but it's not as if he's trying to win the tour de france seven times in a row while telling us all he is the worlds greatets living athlete while jacking up..................now that would deserve being strung up by the mutsnuts.

    But all he is doing is telling us what he thinks of very expensive bikes, which he is more qualified to do than any of us, having rode them for a living. If you really want to get me started, ask why procycling review 5 grand bikes instead of ones i can afford and want to buy!!!!!!!!!! I'd love to know if i should buy an £800 scott, trek, Giant, Focus....................

  • If magazines such as 'Pro Cycling' truly wanted to take the real moral high ground they should surely stop writing about and in turn serving the commercial interests of riders, teams and managers known or strongly suspected to be involved in doping. However, I wonder what they would fill their pages with if they could no longer write about US Postal/ Discovery, Armstrong, Landis, Basso, Ullrich, Vinokourov, Kashechkin, Mayo and come to that the great majority of people involved in the meaningless circus that professional cycling has become?

    As to employing Andreu. Good on them. At least he has had the balls to come clean as to his activities in the past. I also feel much of the criticism is motivated by those who resent the way Andreu (and of course his wife) have played such an important role in the exposure of the reality behind the Armstrong myth.

  • My only problem with Frankie doing the bike tests is his size. Many bikes at the top of the size range will handle differenrlt to the more common 56cm and 58cm models. I had a similar problem with Chris Boardman. Every time he tested a custom bike it was to his rather strange (to the average rider) requirments. Please keep Marcel on for as long as you can.

    I second the post re cheaper bikes. Cycling + covers the range up to £1500 fairly well but can Procycling have a look at some in the £1500 to £2500 range which is what many are buying now.

  • Like most of us who raced or supported the racers, I've know Frankie for years. Everyone in the racing community respected Frankie Andreu. You never heard a bad word about him. We all enjoyed his work on-screen after he retired. He's not a devious guy; you don't feel that there's an agenda or that he's being anything but forthright.

    If I had a son, I'd be delighted if he were Frankie Andreu.

    If Frankie made a mistake, if he weakened and reached out for illicit assistance, he's not the first of us to do so. All human bike riders suffer the occasional bad patch. Congratulations to Procycling for hiring him.

    Go Frankie!

  • Jeez, why don't PROCYCLING and Frankie Andreu just go get a room - it's embarrasing - ...!

  • 1

Post comment:

You need to login or register to post comments.

The Magazine

This issue

September 2009, issue 129 – on sale in the UK on 13 August (early September in the US and ROW)

It's the Tour de France issue – the most explosive interviews, most in-depth features and most spectacular photos…

  • Stories and interviews written from the roadside. Procycling talks to Tour organiser Christian Prudhomme, multiple stage winner Mark Cavendish and even the man who prints the shirts for the podium presentations
  • How Alberto Contador rode to his first Tour victory despite his own team rather than because of them
  • Exclusive Bernhard Eisel Tour diary. Find out what it was like to share in Columbia-HTC's glory
  • PLUS
  • 12-page Vuelta preview. The routes, the stage profiles and a bit of history along the way too
  • Marcel Wüst road tests the Basso Astra
  • Your guide to the next month in racing with The Program

PLUS

A whole lot more including exclusive columns from Garmin's Dan Martin, Saxo Bank's Frank Hoj and Gianni "The Prince" Savio 

Next issue

October 2009, issue 130 – on sale 10 September

  • News, views and interviews from the pro peloton, including a face-to-face with Andy Schleck and a look at one of the darker aspects of the sport

PLUS

  • Marcel Wust tests the Giant TCR

Buy online now

Available in Barnes & Noble in the US – find your nearest store

Buy online now

Available in Barnes & Noble in the US - find your nearest store

Buy online now