Technique: Why hip angle is crucial when using tri bars

By Garth Fox, Triathlon Plus | Monday, Jan 17, 2011 4.00pm

So you've invested in some tri bars for your bike? Great! All you need to do now is get nice and low at the front so that your chin’s almost scraping on the road and before you know it you’ll be slashing minutes off your time trial times, all because you create less drag.

So clip them on and let’s get flying, I hear you say. Well, yes and no... It would be nice if it were that straightforward, but there’s a lot more to consider than just aerodynamics.

Yes, tri bars are the simplest and cheapest way of cycling faster for the same effort, because your body, and specifically your frontal area which meets the wind, accounts for over 60 percent of your total aerodynamic drag. By allowing you to get lower, they do more to improve the profile you present to the wind than other, more expensive components, frames or wheels will ever do. What's more, they're easy to fit to almost any bike and very adjustable.

It's important to spend some time getting used to new kit before you race and that's certainly true with tri bars. But you also need to be wary when adopting an aero position. The conclusions of a recent research study, which I conducted at Brunel University, suggested that riding while crouched low on your tri bars may reduce the amount of power you're able to produce.

Aero bar testing

We tested age group triathletes over a 20-minute cycling time trial followed immediately by a 15-minute run at self-selected 5K race pace. They cycled in a crouched aero position as well as in the more upright position of riding with hands on the hoods. We measured average power produced on the bike, as well as their running economy.

Not only did we find that the triathletes produced an average of eight percent more power when cycling in the upright cycling position, but perhaps more surprisingly they also demonstrated a four percent improvement in their running economy. We concluded that the narrower hip angle produced by the crouched aero position may affect muscle recruitment patterns, leading to higher oxygen usage, heart and breathing rates.

Hip angle

So does this mean we should avoid using aero bars? Certainly not. Aero advantages should definitely be on your hit list, but you should aim to achieve your aero position with as large a hip angle as possible. If you have a road bike with tri bars, it's likely that your hip angle is too closed. A well-fitted time trial bike with its steeper frame geometry is more likely to guarantee you increased cycling power and better running performance.

Not all of us can afford, or even want to have, two bikes though. So the key is simply to make sure that, through adjustment of your seat fore/aft position and handlebar height, you keep as open a hip angle as possible while still maintaining a crouched aero position so you can ride fast. So stick with those tri bars, be prepared to spend some time optimising your setup, and there’s no reason you can’t go out and get that new personal best.

Correct Open hip angle

Correct - open hip angle:

Incorrect Closed hip angle

Incorrect - clsoed hip angle:

You can follow BikeRadar on Twitter at twitter.com/bikeradar and on Facebook at facebook.com/BikeRadar.

User Comments

There are 6 comments on this post

Showing 1 - 6 of 6 comments

  • Have you talked to Julian at Cyclefit? He has been trying shorter cranks and finding a marked difference with the more open hip angle

  • This seems to be pretty common knowledge in the pro-cycling world - read any article on wind tunnel testing and TT setup. Chris Boardman also wrote some useful stuff for some of the Tri magazines a couple of years back.

    In the summer I modify one of my road bikes for the Tri season. I change the stem to one with a bigger angle (so the bars are lower), drop it down 20mm or so on the steerer (I have 30mm of spacers) and then fit a zero setback seatpost to bring my hips forward as described (with a TT saddle). I get a good approximation of a TT bike for little outlay although I could do with some deep section wheels......

  • Hip angle is exceedingly important. Thanks for bringing this to light. But, this isn't the whole equation: It's not just having it open; it is a matter of how open it is and how that relates to your flexibility. A good fitter should be measuring your flexibility - particularly that of the hip flexor and using that measurement as their limit for the most aggressive position. This is the practical point of the article. The riders experiencing less available power while pedaling and worse running economy were pushing through their limit of flexibility at the hip flexor on every pedal stroke! Easy mistake to make.

  • The triathletes in the study may well have generated 8% more power, but how many more watts did they have to expend overcoming air resistance because of their upright position? We don't know, because the article fails to address the key point of whether they were faster or slower!

    All that matters in a time trial is how fast you are, and two of the fundamental factors affecting that are how much power you can output and how much air resistance you have to overcome. It may well be worth sacrificing some power output if this is outweighed by the aerodynamic savings (or vice versa).

    Failing to address the overall speed gain (or loss) is a big hole in the discussion above.

  • As a bike fitter there are not just one single factor but many. Hip angle is relative to flexibility and the distance(and time) that the person is going to spend in this position, even for aero bikes. Hip angle should be determined using the handlebar height after finding the proper pedaling position, not crank arm length. If you modify the crank arm length too much you'll deal with loss of power, especially climbs. A good bike fit for the person involving a thorough assessment of the person will do far more for the "average" rider than anything.

  • Id agree it deoends on aerodynamics and an individual riders flexibility.

    Try telling Chris Boardman that a closed hip is no good,.....anyone remember the superman position?

    http://news.bbc.co.uk/olmedia/990000/images/_992941_superman300.jpg

    That was really slow wasn't it!!!!

Post a Comment:

You need to login or register to post comments.