Man jailed for driving attack on cyclist
An Edinburgh driver has been jailed for nine months for deliberately knocking a cyclist off his bike.
According to the Edinburgh Evening News, Tahir Chaudry drove his van at cycle courier Greig Walker and then drove away, leaving Mr Walker with concussion and wounds that required five stitches.
Before the incident on November 3, 2006, Mr Walker had shouted at Mr Chaudry at traffic lights after Mr Chaudry undertook him at a junction. Further up the road, Mr Chaudry did an emergency stop and reversed toward Mr Walker. Mr Walker mounted a verge to get away but after he rejoined the roadway he could hear the van accelerating behind him.
Witnesses said they saw Mr Chaudry swerve the van toward Mr Walker, hitting his bike and throwing him to the ground.
The Edinburgh High Court found Mr Chaudry guilty of dangerous driving, which carries a maximum sentence of two years imprisonment.
Passing sentence, the judge, Lord McEwan, said that he had taken Chaudry’s background and good references into account, but added, “I think in the public interest to suppress road rage I have to pronounce a custodial sentence. I have to take a very serious view of this matter which is a very bad example of road rage.”
Lord McEwan also banned Chaudhry from driving for five years and ordered him to resit a driving test.
Cycle courier community commentator Buffalo Bill recently wrote about the case. “I would say that this was a punishment that was proportionate with the crime, and its consequences,” he said. “It’s also good to see that the police (according to this report) considered laying a charge of attempted murder. … The courts can get it right, if the charges and evidence are properly framed.”
User Comments
There are 3 comments on this post
Showing 1 - 3 of 3 comments
-
leonlikestrees
Posted Fri 30 Nov, 10:18 am UTC Flag as inappropriate
I can't see why this doesn't deserve the full two years? No matter how good his character references, how can deliberately trying to knock a cyclist off in a motorized vehicle be acceptible?
-
pst88
Posted Thu 6 Dec, 11:10 am UTC Flag as inappropriate
Banned from driving for 5 years? That's it? Seems like he got off very lightly for ATTEMPTED MURDER.
-
Svendo
Posted Sat 8 Dec, 5:31 pm UTC Flag as inappropriate
PST88 Its nine months JAIL and a five year ban. It probably wouldn't get a guilty if charged as attempted murder due to reasonable doubt around the state of mind of Mr Chaudry, and the provocation (Albeit deserved). Also does seem in proportion with what death by dangerous driving gets, and the level of the cyclists injuries, i.e. no broken limbs etc, as Buffalo Bill concedes. (I reserve the right to br corrected by more lawyerly types.) Whether the sentences for such offences are stiff enough is another question. Personally I'm more concerned with rehabilitation than with punishment, as in my opinion it's a more effective way to increase my safety from offenders in general using my tax pounds.
And I've had the same thing happen to me, although without such extreme dangerous driving and any actual contact. However outrageous the drivers behaviour from him initially cutting me up, I could have avoided everything else if I'd not gestured at the driver who turned out to have an anger management issue. In brief it's no good being right but dead.
- 1










Post this story to: