Stages Cycling StageONE power meter – Interbike 2012
By James Huang in Boulder, Colorado | Monday, September 17, 2012 2.00pm
Stages Cycling's new StageONE power meter could very well change the landscape of the segment, offering a seemingly reliable, consistent, and accurate direct measurement system that's far cheaper than any other competitor James Huang/BikeRadar
Boulder, Colorado-based company Stages Cycling is launching a new direct-measurement power meter at Interbike that weighs just 20g and costs as little as $699.
The StageONE power meter is built into slightly modified left-hand crankarms and directly measures power via a strain gage array, custom electronics, and a special algorithm that filters out non-applicable forces and interpolates total left-plus-right output. Claimed accuracy is within +/-2 percent.
StageONE is a new product, but it's based on a simpler design Stages Cycling has validated on more than 7,000 similar systems built into commercial exercise bikes. StageONE, however, comes in a much smaller, lighter and sleeker package.
Claimed weight for the entire system is just 20g. It adds less than 10mm to the inner profile of the crankarm. And once installed (with no holes or structural changes required, mind you), it's barely noticeable with virtually zero effect on a bike's aesthetics.
20g is a very small price to pay for power measurement
Since the system is based on a left-hand crankarm exclusively, it should also be very easy to transfer between multiple bikes with no effect on the drivetrain adjustment and no recalibration when swapping chainrings. Users will still be able to retain power measurement when swapping between racing and training wheels or different pedals, too.
As if that weren't enough, Stages Cycling claims the StageONE incorporates ambient temperature compensation to retain accurate readings, it measures cadence without having to install a separate magnet on your bike anywhere, it transmits data via both ANT+ and Bluetooth Smart protocols for maximum compatibility with both existing head units and many popular smartphones, claimed battery life is more than 200 hours, and the standard CR2032 battery is easily replaceable at home.
Stages does not make its own head unit, and has no plans to do so. So you will have to own an ANT+ bike computer (like a Garmin 500) or a Bluetooth 4.0 smartphone to read and record power data.
And for those keeping track, the StageONE is completely manufactured in the United States – even the plastic casing – with the lone exception of the circuit boards, which are currently printed in Taiwan.
That feature set would be impressive for any direct-measurement power meter but that the StageONE is priced so relatively inexpensively is merely icing on the cake. According to Stages Cycling vice president of product development Doug Crawford, the goal of the StageONE is simply to "bring more people into power."
We tested the StageONE (blue) against a PowerTap (red)
You can't have it all – or can you?
Stages Cycling readily admits that it's not necessarily trying to go head-to-head with established players such as SRM, Powertap, and Quarq in terms of outright technology, instead preferring to go after so-called 'blue collar' riders who merely want a consistent means of tracking progress for training purposes.
Along those lines, the StageONE does hold a few disadvantages. Being a left-only system, it relies on a mathematical algorithm to calculate total power output so it can't display more advanced features such as left/right power balance. Moreover, it also assumes that a rider's output will be the same between both legs.
BikeRadar was granted an exclusive first test ride on the new StageONE during a visit to the company headquarters and while overall correlation to the Powertap hub we had installed concurrently was very impressive, a quick analysis of our hour-long session data also appeared to reveal that this particular tester pedals harder with his right leg.
Stages Cycling will also have to convince some riders to ditch their existing carbon crankarms – or at least just one of them. While StageONE's January 2013 release date will include an impressive fourteen models – even including downhill, BMX, and track cranks – inherent problems with hysteresis associated with composite construction means the StageONE will only work with aluminum arms.
You can get a StageONE power meter on any major crank arm you like - as long as it's aluminum
That being said, company marketing director Matt Pacocha [who, in the interest of full disclosure, most recently worked as BikeRadar's US editor] says swapping from a carbon fiber Truvativ X0 crank to an aluminum X9 adds only 36g in total.
In addition, Stages Cycling estimates the StageONE will fit on roughly 90 percent of road and 'cross frames but some full-suspension mountain bike configurations – and especially downhill bikes – could present clearance issues. Stages Cycling says it will post a constantly updated compatibility list on its website.
Such a construction method also begs the question of retrofits. However, Stages Cycling builds every power meter exclusively into new crankarms sourced directly from the manufacturers and currently has no plans to offer retrofits for buyers that already own compatible units.
Even at such a relatively inexpensive price, perhaps the biggest hurdle Stages Cycling will have to face is convincing buyers that it isn't just some plastic box glued onto a crankarm. Stages Cycling wouldn't allow us to photograph the bare inner workings but interested parties should remind themselves that the casing merely encloses the more intricate and complex workings hidden inside.
"It's high-tech but simple," Crawford told BikeRadar. "It's elegant and it looks simple but that's just refined engineering."
If the StageONE indeed can offer consistent readings as promised, though, none of those modest potential pitfalls will matter. Cyclists will finally be able to use directly measured power data for more effective training at a price point previously restricted to the secondhand market, or computed solutions such as iBike, and depending on how the StageONE is received, none of us may ever look at power meter pricing the same way ever again.
The battery has a claimed life of 200 hours, and it is user replaceable without recalibration
The complete model and pricing run-down is as follows, based on crank manufacturer:
Cannondale BB30: Price TBD
- Hollowgram SI SL (pre-2012, road/mtn power meter only)
- Hollowgram SI SL2 road
- Hollowgram SI SL2 mountain
- Hollowgram SI road
- Hollowgram SI mountain
- Dura-Ace 9000, $949 power meter; $1,349 complete crankset
- Dura-Ace 7900, $899 power meter; $1,299 complete crankset
- Ultegra 6700, $799 power meter; $1,099 complete crankset
- 105 5700, $699 power meter
- Dura-Ace Track, $899 power meter
- XTR, $899 power meter
- XT, $799 power meter
- Saint, $899 power meter
- DXR, $899
- X9 GXP, $699 power meter; $899 complete crankset (Compatible with X7, X9, X0, XX [166mm Q model], and many other Truvativ
- X9 BB30, $699 power meter; $949 complete crankset
- Rival OCT GXP, $699 power meter; $899 complete crankset (Compatible with Apex, Rival, Force, Red, Truvativ Omnium (track), and many other Truvativ models)
High-end SRAM users will have to downgrade to an aluminum crank. There are currently no Campagnolo models
BikeRadar is not responsible for the
content of external websites
You can follow BikeRadar on Twitter at twitter.com/bikeradar and on
Facebook at facebook.com/BikeRadar.
can also improve your fitness and train with us on training.bikeradar.com.