Genesis Croix De Fer review

Change Currency What's this?
The steel frame means the Croix De Fer  remains comfortable over distances

BikeRadar verdict

3.5 out of 5 stars

"Great handling; heavy compared with a CX racer but lighter than a full-blown tourer"

Fri 16 Dec 2011, 8:00 am GMTBy

Plenty of bike makers now offer a cyclo-cross inspired, do-anything machine. Genesis were among the first with their Croix de Fer, a bike designed to blast bridleways or tackle tarmac equally well.

We praised the 2011 Croix de Fer's comfort and ability to mix it with mountain bikes in the rough, but considering a modified version had been ridden around the world by Vin Cox in a record-breaking 163 days, the lack of mounts for a front rack undermined its touring credentials.

The 2012 machine puts that right, though you’ll still need a disc-specific rear rack to clear the seatstay-mounted disc brake. Changes to the gearing also make the bike better suited to loaded riding. The cassette is now 10-speed instead of nine, and rather than bottoming out with a 25, there’s a 28-tooth sprocket to keep you pedalling rather than pushing.

The lower bottom gear makes the Croix de Fer even more at home off-road. ’Cross racers may be happy to get off and run, but we got plenty of use from the 28T sprocket on steep bridleways. Point the bike back the other way and you’ll be glad of the steel frame and fork’s forgiving ride.

It’s noticeably more comfortable than similarly priced aluminium cyclo-cross bikes, but the fork’s lateral stiffness and the frame’s sorted geometry keep the bike on course. In fact, it makes mountain bikes seem like overkill for a lot of off-road riding.

You do notice some drag from the 35mm Continental Cyclocross race tyres on tarmac, especially when climbing, but pump them up to 85psi or so and they roll surprisingly well. As a tyre for all surfaces and weathers they’re a good compromise, though a change to durable slicks would be a good call for on-road commuting.

Make use of the mudguard mounts and you’ll arrive at the office clean and dry, while the Avid BB-7 cable disc brakes give reliable all-weather stopping once they’ve bedded in. If you harbour ambitions in the local ’cross league, bear in mind the Croix de Fer’s weight. It’s trim compared with full-blown tourers but lardy next to a ’crosser, and the skinny Reynolds 725 frame does flex when you stamp on the pedals.

The distinctive head tube badge: the distinctive head tube badge

This article was originally published in Cycling Plus magazine.

What's the score with BikeRadar reviews? You can find a full explanation of our ratings here.

User Reviews

There are 6 reviews on this post

Showing 1 - 6 of 6 comments

  • With oversized bars, and those "cross-top" brake levers taking up the only non-tapering sections, you'd struggle to find anywhere to fix most front lights. Which isn't so good for the commuting role mentioned in the review. What is the point of oversized bars anyway, especially on a bike that clearly isn't intended for racing? I guess Genesis just don't want to keep more than one clamp size in their inventory of parts.

  • Well I love mine. had it for three months. the point of an oversized bar is that you can make a stronger bar with less flex that weighs a bit less due to the thiner wall section of the tube. It also means you have a good choice of after market stems and bars, given that any made after the 70's will probably be 31.8 anyway. I took the sissy levers off anyway so have had no trouble mounting my hope light. Ive commuted on the bike and even taken it on some winter mtb night rides. (dont tell genesis but she jumps medium sized doubles like a dream), the reynolds tubing gives a lovely smooth but supple ride and the disk brakes are a massive improvement over my old cross bike (2011 spesh crux) yea if your after a pure race machine its probably a bit heavy (or you need to m.t.f.u.) but if your buying a pure race bike you probably wont be buying a steel bike anyway. And if your after a pure race bike/amaizing tourer/do it all bike then your asking too much from a bike at this budget, you know? compromises have to be made somwhere.

    If your after a really well thought out (this is the third gen cdf so genesis have really had chance to refine it to perfection) do anything bike at a damn good price given the spec, I seriously cant recommend this enough. Its my white swiss army ride and fast becoming one of my favorite two wheeled companions.

  • It might be heavy for a Cross bike, but its light for a tourer...

    I wish they mounted the rear brake inside the rear triangle like others are now doing ... would eliminate requirement for disc specific rear rack.

  • im a mountain biker so its light to me anyway, I think its about two or three mins slower (on nobblys) over a ten mile commute than my old crux on slicks which isnt bad, and it just rides sooooooooo good! =)

  • It's heavier than my mid-range hybrid but lighter than my mountain bike... but once past the initial acceleration it's no slouch. The standard 35mm contis do drag a bit and the 25-26lb weight is noticeable climbing but to be honest a few mins longer on a 25 mile run might make all the difference if you're racing but not for the average recreational rider. The extra brake levers do compromise a bit of space but I've got two front lights (and a wireless computer mounted on the stem) on mine. The brakes are great! As expected it's pretty comfortable (apart from the standard seat) and if you're touring laden and travelling through hilly regions a 12-30T cassette will fit straight on (I have a 11-32T on mine and it works fine... but at the limit for the std derailleur and chain.

  • I have a 2011 bike. Can only repeat the praise of others really. Yes its no lightweight, but I think the wheels are more at fault for that than people realise - they are excessively heavy and the Deore hubs seem to resist accelerating downhill. Will be swapping them out for hope hubs with stans rims soon.

    Brakes are ok and reliable, but the Shimano's (Avid for 2012) arent as potent as rim brakes in the dry. Just in the process of fitting Hope V-twin's. Have fitted a Tubus Disco rack which cleanly fits past the calipers, but it would be nice to see them being moved inside the rear triangle for 2013.

    Also Genesis will persist with a terrible saddle and cheap bartape. I also found the headset and seatpost clamp to be nasty cheap items as well.

Submit Your Review:

You need to login or register to post comments.

Specification

Name:
Croix De Fer (12)
Built by:
Genesis Bikes
Price:
n/a

Weight (kg):
11.7

Frame & Fork:

 
Frame Material:
reynolds 725 steel
Fork Model:
Chromoly steel

Brakes:

 
Brakes Model:
Avid BB-7 discs

Transmission:

 
Rear Derailleur Model:
shimano Tiagra
Front Derailleur Model:
shimano Tiagra
Shifters Model:
shimano Tiagra

Wheels:

 
Rims Model:
Alex xd-Lite

:

 
Description:
Conti tyres, in-line brake levers

Related links

Also on BikeRadar