Giant XTC 29er review

|

$2000

Change Currency What's this?
The wide bars give plenty of leverage to hold lines or push the inside line through turns

BikeRadar verdict

4 out of 5 stars

"Not cheap, but this fast yet capable ride is the best off-the-peg alloy framed 29er hardtail we’ve ridden"

Sun 26 Dec 2010, 8:00 am GMTBy

Giant launched their XTC 29er last year and, typically for the brand, it proved an outstanding performer for those specifically after speed and rigidity. The package has only been tweaked slightly for 2011 but the results are outstanding.

Whatever handling, control, confidence or speed criteria you’re scoring it on, the XTC is one of the best shop-ready big-wheeled hardtails we've tested, with only a significant price increase over the previous model letting it down.

Ride & handling: New rolling stock makes a good ride truly great

When jumping between different aluminium bikes on group rides during testing, you could almost hear the purr from whoever switched to the Giant. Stiffness through the steering and pedals with subtlety through the seat is the holy grail of hardtail design, and Giant’s bike balance is pretty much spot-on.

The precision and placement of the front wheel through the screw-through axle fork tips, up the tapered steerer in the twist-free front end, and into the wide, flat bars was a highlight last year and it still shines this year. While you could go a shade shorter, the 90mm stem is a good balance between straightline speed stability with racer’s reach and reasonable singletrack responsiveness.

The wide bars give plenty of leverage to hold lines or push the inside line through turns, and the super-short rear end carves in tight behind. Big, short stays give a very direct link between your shoe sole and the rear wheel too, helping the Giant to avoid the big-wheeled laziness common of many 29ers.

The Giant PXC2 rims are slightly lighter and more flexible than those on last year's XTC 29er. This means they trade a tiny amount of stiffness in turns and rocky pinball situations for a noticeable increase in overall ride quality. While the XTR 29er is no feather bed there’s now enough smoothness in the back end to mean multi-hour rides aren’t a shortcut to the chiropractor.

The rims are still wide enough to fatten up the super-light Maxxis Aspen tyres enough to shrug off rocks and edges far better than the previous Kenda rubber. Considering how fast they roll and accelerate, grip levels are outstanding on all but the wettest trails.

This all comes together to create a bike that’s slightly slower off the mark than an equivalent 26in race hardtail but doesn’t force you to back off the minute the trail gets technical. Momentum, traction, shifting smoothness, rider comfort and rough terrain are all enhanced, and the fact we managed to bend the saddle rails without noticing is a prime example of just how hard you can hammer this bike without it showing. 

Frame & equipment: £250 more than last year, but you do get 30-speed gears, better wheels and tyres

Giant certainly get things off to the right start with their Overdrive head tube and matching tapered steerer Fox QR15 fork. The oversized hexagonal Megadrive down tube shares a long seam with the shallow but broad top tube, which then tapers and slopes back dramatically to the slim, subtly kinked seat tube. This lets Giant bring the rear wheel in super close on big rectangular chainstays, but lack of cross bracing still means reasonable mud room. It’s still an IS brake mount though.

Giant’s new P-XC2 rims are much shallower and 35g lighter for a more forgiving, faster reacting ride feel than last year’s hoops. They’re also shod with our favourite Maxxis Aspen 29er tyres. You get an upgrade to a Shimano SLX chainset and Dyna-Sys shifters for a full 30-speed transmission. Shimano’s powerful and consistently sharp feeling M445 brakes take over stopping duty from Avid.

Giant finishing kit still includes their specific wide, flat 29er bars, but there’s none of the blue anodised colour coding of last year. The only obvious downside (besides the £250 price hike) compared to last year’s bike is that the saddle is now a Giant own-brand item which we bent the rails on, rather than last year’s Fizik Tundra.

What's the score with BikeRadar reviews? You can find a full explanation of our ratings here.

User Reviews

There are 8 reviews on this post

Showing 1 - 8 of 8 comments

  • Is it going to be available frame only?

  • i got a 2010 model in march having spent two years riding a fisher 29er. To say that mr fisher has been pushing the 29er thing for so long , how come his bikes ride so bad compared with giants first attempt????. the giant rides a lot better than a fisher in all areas. it,s not been plane sailing with the giant , rims tubeless errr not!! seat post crap thank you mr thomson and kenda tyres wouldn't put them on a wheelie bin. All have now been sorted out and its fast . Don't believe me demo one.

  • Id really like to give the XTC a spin and see if it lives up to the hype, if its better than my 26 XTC it would be very good indeed

    Id be really interested to see if Liam Killeen ends up riding the Anthem and XTC 29ers next season, if him and Oli end up on one the deal would be well and truly sealed as far as im concered........ if they dont however, well all this could be the best marketing hype ever

  • [quote]Is it going to be available frame only?[/quote]

    Don't be silly - only US! (been there and tried - let me know if you have any luck!!)

  • Looks like a great bike but why on earth are they not offering this in an XL frame size?

  • @rodwell

    If you've never ridden Giant's bikes, they size pretty large.

  • Had this bike for two weeks: awesome stiff frame and front end: precise through twisty singletrack. Steering marginally slower than my old 26er (to be expected) but more than made up by traction, awesome fork and general ability to roll over rough terrain.

    Components very good Fizik tundra saddle is firm but perfectly shaped - don't know about longevity (given it hasn't got reinforced edges) so I've swapped it for a ritchey marathon and put the tundra on my road bike!

    Niggles: high front end and wide bar is a little weird. I intend to cut the bars to shoulder width and whack on some ergon grips.. then it'll be perfect.

    I'm happy... I'm definitely a convert to the 29er cult.

  • Addit: I'm 5'8" and got a medium... I have short legs so toptube clearence is just adequate. This bike has a short top-tube so medium perfect for me. This has a high front end: I had to swap the stem over to get an adequately low front end: next step is probably to remove a couple of spacers and trim the steerer. I'm not some ultra flexible rider either... the front end is pretty high.....

Submit Your Review:

You need to login or register to post comments.

Specification

Name:
XTC 29er (11)
Built by:
Giant
Price:
$2000.00

Available Sizes:
S (16"), S (16"), S (16"), M (18"), L (20"), S (16"), M (18"), L (20"), S (16"), M (18"), L (20"), L (20"), M (18"), M (18"), L (20")
Available Colours:
Black
Weight (kg):
11.64
Weight (lb):
25.6

Frame & Fork:

 
Frame Material:
Alu
Fork Brand:
Fox
Fork Model:
F29 RL
Rear Shock Brand:
N/A
Rear Shock Model:
N/A
Headset Brand:
FSA
Headset Type:
Integrated tapered

Geometry:

 
Seat Angle:
73 Degrees
Head Angle:
71 Degrees

Brakes:

 
Brake Levers:
505
Brakes Brand:
Shimano
Brakes Model:
445

Transmission:

 
Cranks Brand:
Shimano
Cranks Model:
SLX
Bottom Bracket Brand:
Shimano
Bottom Bracket Model:
External
Rear Derailleur Brand:
Shimano
Rear Derailleur Model:
XT
Front Derailleur Brand:
Shimano
Front Derailleur Model:
SLX
Shifters Brand:
Shimano
Shifters Model:
SLX 30
Chain Brand:
Shimano
Chain Model:
HG74
Cassette:
Shimano HG81
Pedals Brand:
N/A
Pedals Model:
N/A

Wheels:

 
Rims Brand:
Giant
Rims Model:
P-XC2
Front Hub Brand:
Giant
Front Hub Model:
Tracker
Rear Hub Brand:
Shimano
Rear Hub Model:
M529
Spokes:
Stainless steel
Front Tyre Model:
Maxxis Aspen
Rear Tyre Model:
Maxxis Aspen

Contact Points:

 
Saddle Brand:
Giant
Saddle Model:
XtC
Seatpost Brand:
Giant
Seatpost Model:
Connect
Stem Brand:
Giant
Stem Model:
Connect
Handlebar Brand:
Giant
Handlebar Model:
Contact
Grips/Tape Brand:
Giant
Grips/Tape Model:
Sole O

:

 
Chainstays (in):
18.2
Seat Tube (in):
18 in
Standover Height (in):
30.3 (in)
Top Tube (in):
23.4 in
Wheelbase (in):
43.2 in

Related links