Cotic BFe Silver special first ride review

Cotic’s aggro hardtail gets fully stretched for full-gas riding

GBP £1,929.00 RRP
Skip to view product specifications

Twelve years after this burlier version of Cotic’s classic Soul trail hardtail first appeared, the fifth-generation BFe frame gets a radical geometry refresh that makes it much happier with big forks.


Cotic BFe Silver special specifications

  • Frame: ‘FM’ double-butted steel with Reynolds 853 down tube
  • Fork: X-Fusion Sweep HLR Roughcut, 140mm (5.5in) travel
  • Drivetrain: Shimano SLX with Race Face Æffect Cinch cranks
  • Wheelset: WTB ST i25 TCS rims on Shimano Deore hubs
  • Tyres: WTB Vigilante Light/High Grip (f) and WTB Breakout Tough/High Grip (r) 27.5×2.3in
  • Brakes: Shimano Deore M615, 180/160mm rotors
  • Bar: Cotic Calver, 780mm
  • Stem: Cotic Short, 35mm
  • Seatpost: X-Fusion Manic 150mm dropper
  • Saddle: Cotic
  • Weight: 13.82kg (30.5lb), large size without pedals
  • Seat tube: 48cm
  • Top tube: 61.4cm
  • Head angle: 66°
  • Seat angle: 72°
  • Chainstay: 42cm
  • Bottom bracket drop: 1.76cm
  • Head tube length: 12cm
  • Reach: 44.03cm
  • Stack: 56.82cm

Cotic BFe Silver special frame

Cotic has largely kept to its well-proven recipe. The down tube is ultra-tough yet light Reynolds 853 steel while the rest of the frame is Cotic’s custom ‘FM’ double-butted steel.

Wide-splayed, brace-free chainstays mean there’s loads of mud clearance for 27.5×2.6in or 26x3in tyres. Neat cylindrical bolt-through 142x12mm Syntace dropouts include a pinch-bolt-secured replaceable derailleur hanger, which is rare for steel.

Cables are bolt clamped, and because there’s just a single set of bottle cage bosses (on the down tube), you can slam the seatpost. There are ISCG chain device tabs on the threaded bottom bracket (BB) shell too.

The 657mm effective top tube length on the large I tested is 45mm longer than the previous BFe, which translates to a massive 472mm reach. While the 66-degree head angle is the same, the geometry has been optimised around a 140mm-travel fork, making the seat angle an acceptable 73 degrees. There are no XS or XL sizes, but the frame is well priced at £449.

There’s loads of mud room and the BFe will happily accept 2.6in rubber
Mick Kirkman / Immediate Media

Cotic BFe Silver special kit

The standard ‘Silver’ build comes with a 35mm Cotic stem and 780mm bar, Shimano SLX gears, and Deore brakes and hubs on eyeletted WTB i25 rims with Continental tyres, for £1,629.

Cotic offers extensive upgrade options, and my build included an X-Fusion Sweep 140mm-travel fork with upgraded Roughcut HLR damper (+£100) rather than the standard RL spec, an X-Fusion Manic dropper post (+£150) and WTB tyres set up tubeless (+£50).

Maxxis 2.3 or 2.5in rubber is also available (+£100), plus Hope wheels (+£200) and WTB carbon rims (+£1,200). You can also choose from SRAM and Shimano-based ‘Gold’ builds.

For international pricing and delivery information contact Cotic direct.

Cotic BFe Silver special ride impressions

The extra-long reach lets you carry a ton of speed into turns without tripping up or sliding out
Mick Kirkman / Immediate Media

While it might be the beefiest of Cotic’s hardtails, the wide spread, slim stays and carefully butted and shaped mainframe still give a notably forgiving ride quality.

This is most obvious when trying to maintain flow through random rocks and stutter bumps that would kill speed and punish your feet and hands on most hardtails — the BFe just skips through sweetly.

While it’s good with 2.3in tyres at medium pressures, the BFe floats through trouble even better on the Maxxis WT 2.5in tyres and wider rims I swapped in for some of the testing period. They also add extra compliant traction for an even more positive climbing and cornering feel.

Even in stock form, the extra-long reach lets you carry a ton of speed into turns without tripping up or sliding out, and it’s slack enough to self-correct if you push too hard. The super-short stem helps you micro-manage grip really well too, although you’ll have to learn to swing the front end wide through tight sections.

Unsurprisingly, the extra-long steel frame can sometimes feel a bit vague when you’re flat out, but by that point you’ll have left most hardtails way behind.

It’s still light and lively enough to be enjoyable through the pedals too, whether you’re cruising between the best bits, hustling singletrack hard or on the nose of the saddle up a super-steep tech challenge.

Once it’s bedded in, the Sweep fork is a very well-damped unit, if not as stiff at the ragged edge as 35mm RockShox or 36mm Fox forks. It’s worth noting that a 150–160mm fork will tip the seat angle back to the point where it’s likely to give a vague steering feel when you’re in the saddle, so I’d say 120–140mm is definitely the sweet spot for fork travel with the BFe.


Cotic BFe Silver special early verdict

Radical reshape gives the BFe the handling and wider tyre compatibility the frame deserves.

Product Specifications


Name BFe Silver special
Brand Cotic

Available Sizes S M L
Saddle Cotic
Wheelset WTB ST i25 TCS rims on Shimano Deore hubs
Weight (kg) 13.82
Stem Cotic Short, 35mm
Shifters Shimano SLX
Seatpost X-Fusion Manic 150mm dropper
Seat Angle 72
Rear Tyre WTB Breakout Tough/High Grip 27.5x2.3in
Brakes Shimano Deore M615, 180/160mm rotors
Rear Derailleur Shimano SLX
Head Angle 66
Handlebar Cotic Calver, 780mm
Front Tyre WTB Vigilante Light/High Grip 27.5x2.3in
Frame Material 'FM' double-butted steel with Reynolds 853 down tube
Fork X-Fusion Sweep HLR Roughcut, 140mm (5.5in) travel
Cranks Race Face Æffect Cinch cranks
Frame size tested L