On-One Whippet Alfine 11 review

|

£1599

On-One Whippet Alfine 11

BikeRadar verdict

60.0 out of 5 stars

"We can’t argue with the ride quality of carbon with hub gears, but a race bike isn’t the best platform"

Wednesday, February 1, 2012 8.00am By

Originally conceived as a carbon fibre version of On-One’s aluminium Scandal frameset, the Whippet was one of the first bikes to bring affordable carbon technology to the masses. It's now available with the option of an eight- or 11-speed Shimano Alfine transmission. We’re won over by the combination of price, low weight, carbon comfort and hub gear simplicity, but we’re not entirely convinced that a race bike is the right platform. 

Ride & handling: Great value, lightweight speed machine with the simplicity of hub gears

Stretched long and low over the Whippet’s light, stiff frame, there’s no doubting this bike’s intent. The uncompromising ride position won’t suit all riders, but for racers – or converting roadies – it’s immediately identifiable as a stance that maximises effort at the pedalling coal face. Put simply, this is a bike that wants to go fast.

That efficient position is given a big boost by the Whippet’s low weight, supremely stiff rear end and, you may be surprised to hear, its sublime comfort. Yes, you read that right – this is a light, stiff, fast race bike that’s almost uncannily comfortable through the rough and tumble of flat-out trails. 

Well engineered carbon frames are renowned for their ability to absorb vibration, and the Whippet proves it. Carbon fibre’s great advantage is that it can be laid up in different thicknesses, direction and overlaps to change the strength, weight, flexibility or vibration damping properties of a given area.

As for the hub gears, we’re torn. On the one hand the lack of chain slap and single shifter simplicity meshes well with the Whippet’s single-minded intent. On the other, backing off pedalling to shift on a bike that’s built for speed is rather counterintuitive, even if it is only momentary. 

Although the Whippet’s basic geometry numbers aren’t that far removed from the trail riding norm, the narrow bars and low, stretched ride position scream flat-out speed. Although you could fit a higher stem and wider riser bar, trail cruisers might be better looking at On-One's Carbon 456 instead. We’d love to try one with an Alfine setup, but that’s not currently an option. How about it, On-One?

Frame: Stiff, light and incredibly comfortable; hub gears add a dose of stealth to match the looks

Although it’s based on the tried-and-tested Scandal geometry, a cursory glance at the Whippet’s flared and bulged plumbing is all you need to tell you that this is a frame designed from the ground up and built from the black stuff. On-One claim a bare frame weight around 1.3kg, or less than 3lb. Given our test bike’s all-up weight of under 11kg (24lb), it’s a claim we can believe.

The Whippet’s bolt-on, adjustable dropouts and twin front mech mounts make it one of the most adaptable hardtail frames out there in terms of gear choice. Whether you want hub, derailleur – in 1, 2 or 3x10 configurations – or singlespeed, the Whippet has it covered.

Despite a price that puts it level pegging with steel-framed competition, our 11-speed test bike was well equipped. A Middleburn singlespeed-specific chainset helps set it apart from the crowd, while the RockShox SID RLT fork provides all the adjustability for its 100mm of air sprung travel that any budding speed freak could ask for. 

Own-brand finishing kit looks good and works well, though the flat bar is a culture shock for riders accustomed to the past decade-and-a-half of riser ubiquity. Thoughtfully, On-One have even specced the black version of Shimano's Alfine hub to match the bike’s understated looks.

This article was originally published in What Mountain Bike magazine.

What's the score with BikeRadar reviews? You can find a full explanation of our ratings here.

User Comments

Submit Your Review:

Specification

Name:
Whippet Alfine (12)
Brand:
On-One
Price:
£1599

Available Sizes:
16" 18" 20" 20"
Bottom Bracket:
Token, press-fit
Brakes:
Shimano SLX hydraulic discs, 160/160mm rotors
Cassette:
Shimano alfine 18T
Chain:
KMC CL566R
Cranks:
Middleburn UnO 32T
Fork:
RockShox SID RLT, air, 100mm
Frame Material:
Carbon composite
Grips/Tape:
On-One lock-on
Handlebar:
On-One alu flat, 600mm
Head Angle:
69
Headset Type:
On-One
Saddle:
Prologo Kappa
Seat Angle:
71.5
Seatpost:
FSa SL-250
Shifters:
Shimano alfine 11
Stem:
Planet X, 85mm
Weight (kg):
10.9
Weight (lb):
24
Bottom Bracket Height (in):
18.25
Chainstays (in):
16.75
Seat Tube (in):
18.25
Standover Height (in):
31
Top Tube (in):
23.75
Wheelbase (in):
43.3
Tyres:
Schwalbe Rocket Ron, 2.25in
Front Wheel:
Stan's ZTR Crest rim, On-One hub, black butted spokes
Rear Wheel:
Stan's ZTR Crest rim, Shimano alfine 11 hub, black spokes

Latest questions

Related links