Giant Trance Advanced 27.5 0 – long-term review

|

£5499

Giant's new Trance Advanced 27.5 0 is an absolute blast when pushed hard

BikeRadar verdict

3.5 out of 5 stars

"Great handling, stiff and lightweight but rear end takes a step back"

Wednesday, January 29, 2014 8.00am By

The new Giant Trance Advanced 27.5 0 headlines the company's huge commitment to mid-sized wheels. This latest flagship is stiff, fantastically light and handles brilliantly, but the rear suspension performance has taken a slight step backward from previous years.

  • Highs: Supple rear suspension, very lightweight, mostly superb component package, brilliant handling
  • Lows: So-so pedaling performance, imbalanced suspension feel, mediocre seatpost

Ride and handling: great handling and precise feel, but the suspension misses a step

Giant has done its homework on the Trance Advanced 27.5 0's frame geometry, with standpoint features like a 67-degree head tube angle and 17.3in chainstays across the five-size range. Coupled with the relatively low bottom bracket and long front centre, the bike is raucously fun and inspires gobs of confidence when the trail points downhill. Simply place the front wheel, weight the tyres appropriately, and rail (or drift) through the corner to the exit – and if anything, the faster, the better.

Nonetheless, the relatively compact rear end – half an inch shorter than on the Trance X 29er 0 we reviewed last year – still lends very good maneuverability in tight, switchback-laden climbs, plus the lower front end affords more flexibility in terms of rider positioning. It's easy to manual when needed, with just a slight rearward weight shift and a subtle tug on the bars needed to get the front end airborne.

Giant says the new trance advanced 27.5 0's revised maestro suspension geometry has been optimized for modern 1x drivetrains but unfortunately, we instead found a substantial decrease in pedaling efficiency versus previous iterations:

Upgrade-minded riders who might be coming off of 26in wheels will be happy to know that the slight increase in wheel diameter doesn't dramatically affect that familiar nimbleness either. The subtle size boost doesn't quite lend the 650b (27.5in) wheels a monster truck-like feel when it comes to just carelessly bombing through rock gardens but it more than makes up for that in terms of agility.

Giant infuses the Trance Advanced 27.5 0 with its familiar Maestro dual-link suspension design and as usual, it does an excellent job of sucking up the terrain. The supple initial stroke utterly erases smaller bumps but without yielding an overly isolating ride quality, while the very progressive spring curve makes similarly short work of bigger hits and drop-offs.

Giant sticks to its tried-and-true maestro suspension design but felt the shift to 1x drivetrains warranted moving the virtual pivot point down 8mm. unfortunately, pedaling efficiency actually degrades substantially as a result with lots of squat under power. turning on the platform valving on the rear shock helps significantly but given the shock placement, it's a long reach down:

We never felt any harsh bottom-outs despite plenty of abuse and a seemingly modest 140mm of travel. In fact, Giant uses the exact same frame for its more enduro-focused Trance Advanced SX range but with a longer-travel fork and reservoir-equipped rear shock.

However, this latest incarnation of Maestro managed to disappoint us in two areas. For one, it loiters in the midstroke more than we would prefer and seems to lack some of the 'pop' of older Maestro-equipped machines. More importantly, it lacks the previous iteration's fantastic pedaling efficiency, even with what is otherwise an admirably rigid frame.

Unless you make regular habit of turning on the platform valving on the RockShox Monarch rear shock – which is situated a long way down near the bottom bracket – there's substantial squat under power and a somewhat dull feel any time you really need to turn on the gas.

Stronger riders might find the stock 32-tooth chainring to be a bit on the small side but we found it to be a good option for all-around trail riding:

We also never got over the sensation that the fork and rear suspension were somewhat imbalanced, even though each end does a good job of keeping their respective wheels on the ground. While the rear end is nicely progressive with great initial sensitivity, the stock RockShox Revelation's Solo Air spring curve is more linear and more reluctant to move off the top.

Swapping to a RockShox Monarch Plus rear shock with a high-volume air can evened things out but not everyone will appreciate the firmer feel that results.

Frame: carbon front end mated to an alloy rear

Giant's top-end trail bike frame uses a carbon fibre front triangle and an all-aluminium rear end, joined together with a pair of forged aluminium suspension links and cartridge bearing pivots all around. The sleek design is also quite the looker with its low-slung top tube (which provides heaps of standover clearance), compact suspension design, and tasteful graphics that drew lots of positive comments.

The giant trance advanced 27.5 0 uses a carbon fiber main frame mated to an aluminum rear end:

Although it looks the same as before, the Maestro suspension layout has seen some revisions this time around that help explain the bike's ho-hum pedaling performance. According to global product marketing manager Andrew Juskaitis, Giant moved the virtual pivot point of the rear end down by a substantial 8mm – supposedly to better accommodate the 1x drivetrain. In doing so, though, Giant has lost much of the anti-squat characteristics that gave the old Trance its fantastic pop.

At almost exactly 2,500g (5.51lb) with the stock shock, rear derailleur hanger and seatpost collar, the frame is nonetheless impressively light – and although we don't have any confirmation of such, it's worth noting that the Advanced nomenclature of our test bike at least theoretically leaves room for an even lighter Advanced SL model with a full carbon rear end.

The post mount rear brake caliper tabs are sized for 160mm rotors. a dt swiss rws 142x12mm thru-axle skewer keeps things tied together out back:

Given that it's a fresh design, it's no surprise that Giant has otherwise given the Trance Advanced 27.5 0 frame the full complement of contemporary features, including a press-fit PF92-compatible bottom bracket shell with a carbon fibre internal sleeve, moulded rubber guards for the down tube and driveside chainstay, post mount rear brake calliper tabs, a direct mount front derailleur stub, moulded-in ISCG05 chainguide mounts, fully internal cable routing, and – finally – 142x12mm through-axle rear dropouts.

Of course, there's also a tapered front end although Giant does stray from the industry norm by using its own OverDrive 2 dimensions with a 1 1/4in upper steerer diameter. Giant claims this boosts front-end rigidity – which it should, in theory – but the effect isn't immediately noticeable, and it complicates stem swaps. In fairness, several aftermarket options are available and if the stock Giant-branded carbon fibre unit's length works for you, it's an excellent piece of kit. If need be, swapping out the upper headset bits will allow you to fit a standard 1 1/8 to 1 1/2in fork.

Giant includes an all-carbon cockpit on the trance advanced 27.5 0. the square-section stem is notably stiff and the bars offer a comfortable, low-rise bend:

We were initially leery of the internal cable routing since there are no guides for the full-length housing. However, the entry and exit holes are generously sized plus the rubber finishing plugs install easily and look pretty good. Feeding the internally routed dropper post line necessitates removing the crank and bottom bracket but aside from that, it's a straightforward process.

Equipment: brilliant XX1 drivetrain, solid Avid brakes, great Giant-branded wheels

Giant has left few holes in the Trance Advanced 27.5 0's spec sheet, as it should be, given the £5,499 / AU$6,799 asking price. Highlights include a SRAM XX1 drivetrain, Avid X0 Trail disc brakes, a 140mm-travel RockShox Revelation RLT3 fork, a Fi'zi:k Gobi XM saddle and mostly carbon fibre finishing kit from the company's own-branded parts bin, for a total weight of just 10.88kg (23.98lb; medium, tubeless, without pedals).

The 140mm-travel rockshox revelation rlt3 is highly capable with a relatively accurate-steering chassis and a smooth stroke. small bump sensitivity could be better and the spring rate seems rather linear, though, and given the frame's handling prowess we would have preferred to see a more aggressive pike instead:

We've written at length about XX1 already and there isn't much to add that hasn't already been said. At least for this discipline, the wide-range 1x11 format works exceptionally well with excellent chain retention, smooth shifts from the miniscule 10T cog all the way to the monstrous 42T one, and ample gearing for general trail riding. Plus, if the stock 32T chainring doesn't suit you, there are numerous options on either side of that to shift the window.

Avid – and SRAM in general – has taken a royal beating over its hydraulic disc brake reliability in recent years, and rightly so. However, the four-piston X0 Trails go a long way to pulling the company's reputation out of the gutter. Total power is excellent – even with the modest 170mm-diameter front rotor – and it builds smoothly and predictably with a light initial touch. The carbon levers also move with a silky smooth action on cartridge bearing pivots and our brakes required no maintenance over more than five months of testing.

Say what you will about the reliability of other avid hydraulic disc brake models but the xo trails have been mostly trouble-free on bikeradar test bikes to date. power and modulation are excellent, too, and lever feel is outstanding thanks in part to cartridge bearing pivots:

One Avid hallmark – the dreaded 'turkey gobble' – stubbornly sticks around but it only rears its ugly head under hard braking. We managed to kill it almost completely after switching to SwissStop pads.

We were generally satisfied with the RockShox fork, however, with its smooth and predictable stroke, excellent damping characteristics, and handy 20mm travel reduction switch located atop the crown. The far stiffer – but only marginally heavier – Pike model would better suit the bike's capabilities though, and its more progressive spring rate would more closely match the rear end as well.

The rockshox revelation rlt3 dual position air fork can be dropped from 140mm down to 120mm of travel with the simple flick of the wrist for to help keep the front end down on steep climbs:

There are few complaints to be had with the Giant-branded P-TRX 0 carbon wheels, however, which are noticeably light, impressively stiff, and admirably durable, going up against countless rock strikes with just minor scarring to show for it. The proper UST profile and airtight rim tape make for relatively easy tubeless conversions too, although some tyres will require a compressor to seat.

The matching Schwalbe Nobby Nic tyres are likewise very lightweight and roll faster than their full-height knobs might suggest. However, they also wear very quickly, are prone to cuts, and require reasonably soft ground in order to get optimum purchase.

Giant is one of many companies jumping headfirst into the 27.5in wheel market:

Some might be put off by the Giant branded carbon bar and stem but rest assured that it's all excellent stuff. The massive moulded carbon stem is ultra-stiff – not to mention light – and the bars feature a comfortable shape with a reasonable width.

We could do without the Giant Contact Switch-R dropper post though. It moves smoothly via a tidy remote lever and the internal routing yields a clean appearance but there's a little more slop than we'd like, plus it's quite long considering there's only 100mm of movement on tap.

Giant's house-brand contact switch-r dropper post moves smoothly but there's a fair bit of play. it also only offers 100mm of movement and is relatively long given the amount of travel:

The verdict: Giant's new flagship trail bike is gloriously light, handles brilliantly, and comes with a top-shelf spec. We had extremely high hopes and really wanted to fall in love with it. However, the mediocre pedaling performance and somewhat disjointed suspension balance are impossible to ignore, betraying what would otherwise be a fantastic machine.

Complete bike specifications

  • Frame: Giant Trance Advanced 27.5, 140mm travel
  • Rear shock: RockShox Monarch RT3
  • Fork: RockShox Revelation RLT3, 120 to 140mm travel
  • Headset: FSA Orbit ZS, 1 1/4 to 1 1/2in tapered
  • Stem: Giant Contact SLR
  • Handlebars: Giant Contact SLR Composite, low-rise
  • Grips: Giant lock-on
  • Front brake: Avid X0 Trail with 170mm Avid HS1 rotor
  • Rear brake: Avid X0 Trail with 160mm Avid HS1 rotor
  • Brake levers: Avid X0 Trail
  • Rear derailleur: SRAM XX1
  • Shift levers: SRAM XX1 trigger
  • Cassette: SRAM XX1, 10-42T
  • Chain: SRAM XX1
  • Crankset: SRAM XX1 GXP, 32T
  • Bottom bracket: SRAM PressFit GXP
  • Pedals: n/a
  • Wheelset: Giant P-TRX0 Composite
  • Front tyre: Schwalbe Nobby Nic Evo, 27.5x2.25in
  • Rear tyre: Schwalbe Nobby Nic Evo, 27.5x2.25in
  • Saddle: Fi'zi:k Gobi XM
  • Seatpost: Giant Contact Switch-R

What's the score with BikeRadar reviews? You can find a full explanation of our ratings here.

User Comments

Submit Your Review:

Specification

Name:
Trance Advanced 27.5 0 long-term
Brand:
Giant
Price:
£5499

Available Sizes:
S M L XL
Bottom Bracket:
SRAM PressFit GXP
Brakes:
Avid XO Trail
Cassette:
SRAM XX1
Chain:
SRAM XX1
Cranks:
SRAM XX1
Fork:
RockShox Revelation RLT3, 120-140mm, OverDrive 2
Frame Material:
carbon fiber, aluminum
Frame Weight:
2500
Front Tyre:
Schwalbe Nobby Nic Evo, 27.5x2.25in
Grips/Tape:
Giant lock-on
Handlebar:
Giant Contact SLR Composite, low-rise
Head Angle:
67
Headset Type:
FSA Orbit ZS, 1 1/4-to-1 1/2in tapered
Rear Derailleur:
SRAM XX1
Saddle:
fi'zi:k Gobi XM
Seat Angle:
73.5
Seatpost:
Giant Contact Switch-R
Shifters:
SRAM XX1 trigger
Stem:
Giant Contact SLR
Weight (kg):
10.88
Wheelset:
Giant P-TRX0 Composite
Year:
2014
Chainring Size (No of Teeth):
32
Weight (lb):
23.98
Brake Levers:
Avid XO Trail
Frame size tested:
M

Latest questions