I tastelessly celebrated the demise of Shimano’s hideous 105-level RS505 hydraulic levers when they left the building for good about a year ago.
Now, alongside the launch of its GRX gravel components, Shimano has replaced the 10-speed Tiagra-level RS405 with an updated — and much nicer looking — design that’s very similar to the 105 R7020 model and which comes with a matching flat-mount brake caliper.
The new ST-4720 promises improved comfort and ergonomics and has redesigned internals. Like Ultegra and 105, it will be available in an alternative version for smaller hands, called the ST-4725.
Its launch is accompanied by a new 48/34t crank option, plus 12mm thru-axle Tiagra hubs coded HB-RS470 and FH-RS470 for front and rear respectively. Although Tiagra remains 10-speed, the hubs are 11-speed compatible.
Original article continues below.
Lumpy and unloved, RS505 levers die on R7000’s altar
- Shimano 105 R7000/R7020 rim and disc brake groupset review
- Shimano unveils 105 R7000 group
- Road bike groupsets: everything you need to know
The lumpen RS505 appeared on the scene way back in 2015, fulfilling the need for a 105-equivalent hydraulic lever at a time when your only other mechanical shifting option was the pricier RS685.
Until the advent of Dura-Ace R9100 (or rather, R9120 and R9170 if we’re being pedantic, and we are), Shimano kept its road disc brake options at arm’s length, declining to grant them full groupset status.
- The RS505s were non-series, which means no groupset branding
Nevertheless, every bike manufacturer on the planet wanted to put discs on their latest road bikes and they needed an affordable option for entry-level and mid-range models, hence the RS505 (and its 10-speed counterpart the RS405).
Don’t get me wrong, the RS505s work absolutely fine. The shifting is hard to fault and the braking is indistinguishable from that of Shimano’s other road hydraulics.
The ergonomics were always slightly more divisive. I never had a problem with them and found the big lumpy hoods at least gave me plenty to rest my hands on.
Some of our testers however didn’t get on well with the square-edged bump created by the bleed port, which can create a pressure point depending on exactly how you grip the lever body.
- Lovely bike, not-so-lovely looking levers
My real beef with the RS505s is their looks — they’re hideous. They make dainty, racy road bikes look oddly front-heavy, and they’re totally out of keeping with the svelte roadie aesthetic I’m desperately trying to cultivate.
Rest in peace, big guy
- Shimano’s new R7020 lever, shown on the right next to a non-hydraulic R7000, looks great
With the handsome new R7020 hydraulic groupset likely to feature on many 2019 bikes, the 2018 models with RS505s are suddenly looking rather frumpy.
This is bad news if you run a bike shop and have stock sitting around but it could work in your favour if you’re a customer shopping around for an end of season bargain in a few months, and you can forgive the RS505s their shortcomings.
- The 10-speed RS405 isn’t any prettier
Given Shimano’s usual pattern of trickling tech down, it seems all but certain that a similar fate will befall the Tiagra-equivalent RS405s in a year or two — Tiagra R5000 (or R6000) anyone?
Will you be pouring one out for the unlovely RS505? Do you like brake levers you can find in the dark? Let us know in the comments.