Cotic Soul (frame only) review

Extensively evolved XC/trail flyer

Our rating 
4.5 out of 5 star rating 4.5
GBP £599.00 RRP

Our review

Lightweight, sweet-riding frame with stretched geometry for blisteringly quick singletrack speed
Buy if, You want a tough and classy frame to take on the trail
Pros: Superb taut-yet-floated, light-yet-tough steel frame, also has radical stretched, speed-boosting singletrack geometry
Cons: Wheel pack and fork on test bike undermined its performance, long frame with short fork feels weird at first
Skip to view product specifications

Now in its fifth generation, Cotic’s Soul is the forefather of ferrous-framed UK trail hardtails. The latest Longshot geometry adds techy climb and descent control without killing responsiveness, but the frame deserves a better wheel pack than the test bike came with…

Advertisement

Cotic Soul frame

Skinny rims, a soft wheel-build and wooden-feeling tyres choked the sample, so give the frame fatter wheels and quality rubber to let it breathe
Mick Kirkman

The Soul has always used Reynolds 853 — the Birmingham firm’s premium air-hardening steel alloy — for its main tubes. But Cotic’s owner, Cy Turner (‘Cy Cotic’, geddit?), has added his own tweaks. The head tube is a neat tapered piece, the double-butted down tube and Ovalform top tube get open-ended gussets, and the oversized seat tube locks down the centre of the bike for powerful drive. 

Super-skinny wishbone seatstays connect onto cowled bolt-through dropouts, and the swerved and kinked chainstays leave room for chunky 27.5×2.6in tyres on wide rims.

It’s light for a steel frame, especially one with a crazy-long 480mm reach (Large). The 66-degree head angle is steep enough but still slack compared to most cross-country/trail hardtails. Cotic doesn’t match it with a steepened seat tube though, which has implications if you want to fit a longer fork. 

While the seat tube has internal dropper post routing, the cable/hose is then directed up the outside of the down tube — a practical solution, but not pretty.

Cotic Soul kit

Cotic offers several full builds. The test bike is a tweaked version of the Shimano SLX-based Silver model and would set you back £2,299.

Upgrades include an X-Fusion Manic dropper and its top-spec Sweep RC HLR fork. While good for a cost-effective unit, this can’t match the control of the latest top-end forks, making it worth paying another £100 for a Cane Creek Helm.

The other thing the Soul deserves is better wheels. Hope Pro 4 hubs are ultra-tough, but the test bike came inconsistently laced into skinny Tech XC rims. Subbing in a set of well-built, wider wheels with 2.6in tyres underlined the Cotic’s ride with a different class of float and traction. Thankfully, wider rims and rubber are part of Cotic’s custom-build menu.

Cotic Soul ride

Luckily, there’s more than enough class in the Cotic frame to shine through even in stock form. 

Cy’s evolution of the Soul tubeset has kept it sweetly balanced from head tube to dropouts. It’s stiff enough to stay accurate in rowdy terrain and deliver taut torque transfer for acceleration kick and climbing drive, but with enough compliance to keep hands fresh and let you flow through trouble rather than clang off it.

The combination of a long reach with a short-travel fork does feel a bit weird at first, but limiting travel to 120-130mm works to make sure the back end isn’t left trying to match the impact absorption of an enduro fork.

 It also helps keep the front end anchored superbly on climbs, carving just the arc you want round power corners and threading through narrow gaps between trees.

The extreme Longshot stretch and short fork can feel odd at first, but boost its climbing as well as descending prowess
Mick Kirkman

Add the muscular rear end, and the Soul is a brilliant technical climber that loves to take the fight to the hill or lighter alloy/carbon race bikes when the going gets interesting. 

The head angle is still steep enough that you can whip the long wheelbase through corners, and if the front tyre does start to slide, the stretched reach gives you forever to re-grab traction through the synapse-fast response of the super-short stem. That makes it a super-fast and agile singletracker, without any laziness or flop in the steering.

While the Soul’s length and low front-end make it hard to pop, hop and manual at first, you’ll soon adjust and get it lofting satisfactorily, if never as eagerly as on the Morf. 

A steeper seat angle would make it work better with longer forks, but Cotic’s sturdier BFe is the obvious choice. If you find the Longshot geometry too remote, then you just go down a frame size and add a longer dropper for a more conventional fit.

Advertisement

Cotic Soul specifications (test bike)

  • Frame: Reynolds 853 main tubes (DZB down tube, Ovalform top tube), 4130 chromoly rear triangle
  • Fork: X-Fusion Sweep RC HLR, 120mm (4.7in) travel
  • Headset: Cane Creek 40
  • Hubs: Hope Pro 4
  • Axles: 15x110mm/12x148mm (Boost)
  • Rims: Hope Tech XC
  • Spokes: Double-butted
  • Wheel Weight: 1,990g (f), 2,720g (r), including tyres
  • Tyres: WTB Vigilante TCS Light/High Grip 27.5×2.3in (f) and WTB Trail Boss TCS Tough/Fast 27.5×2.25in (r)
  • Crankset: Race Face Æffect
  • Bottom Bracket: Race Face X-Type
  • Mech(S): Shimano SLX M7000
  • Shifter(S): Shimano SLX M7000 (1×11)
  • Cassette: Shimano SLX M7000, 11-46t
  • Chain: Shimano HG700
  • Brakes: Shimano Deore M6000, 180mm rotors
  • Bar: Cotic Calver, 780mm
  • Stem: Cotic Short, 35mm
  • Grips: Cotic lock-on
  • Seatpost: X-Fusion Manic 150mm dropper
  • Saddle: Cotic
  • Sizes: XS, S, M, L
  • Size tested: Large
  • Weight: 13.04kg

Product Specifications

Product

Name Soul - Frame Only
Brand Cotic

Description Frame Only
Rear Tyre WTB Trail Boss TCS Tough/Fast 27.5x2.25in
Wheelbase (in) 44.29
Top Tube (in) 26.18
Seat Tube (in) 18.11
Chainstays (in) 16.93
Bottom Bracket Height (in) 12.72
Spoke Type Double-butted
Weight (kg) 13.04
Stem Cotic Short, 35mm
Shifters Shimano SLX M7000 (1x11)
Seatpost X-Fusion Manic 150mm dropper
Seat Angle 71
Saddle Cotic
Rims Hope Tech XC
Rear Wheel Weight 2720
Rear Hub Hope Pro 4
Available Sizes XS S M L
Frame Material Reynolds 853 main tubes (DZB down tube, Ovalform top tube), 4130 chromoly rear triangle
Bottom Bracket Race Face X-Type
Brakes Shimano Deore M6000, 180mm rotors
Cassette Shimano SLX M7000, 11-46t
Chain Shimano HG700
Cranks Race Face Æffect
Fork X-Fusion Sweep RC HLR, 120mm (4.7in) travel
Front Hub Hope Pro 4
Rear Derailleur Shimano SLX M7000
Front Tyre WTB Vigilante TCS Light/High Grip 27.5x2.3in
Front Wheel Weight 1990
Grips/Tape Cotic lock-on
Handlebar Cotic Calver, 780mm
Head Angle 66
Headset Type Cane Creek 40
Frame size tested L