Surly Wednesday review

A versatile, value fat bike

Our rating 
4.0 out of 5 star rating 4.0
GBP £1,500.00 RRP | USD $1,500.00

Our review

An affordable fat bike worthy of upgrading as you go
Buy if, You’re looking for an affordable, go-anywhere machine and are willing to make some upgrades along the way
Pros: Sturdy frame, good trail manners, dropper post compatible
Cons: Stock brake levers lack reach adjust, calipers have poor modulation, low tpi tires don’t maximize traction
Skip to view product specifications

If you’re thinking to yourself “Why the heck would the fine folks at Surly name a fat bike after a day of the week?” then you’re asking the wrong question. Surly’s latest fat bike takes its name from the morose and slightly sadistic younger sister of Pugsley in the The Addams Family.

Advertisement

Although Surly has no plans to discontinue the Pugsley, the Wednesday is certainly a modernized successor to this first widely available production fat bike, introduced way back in 2005.

Less massive, more maneuverable 

surly-wednesday-ht-1455425794628-1dyuaqvglzdwf-1000-90-66a309d
#: #

The Wednesday has a 44mm head tube making it compatible with suspension forks such as the RockShox Bluto

Last year the Surly Ice Cream Truck topped out our fat bike roundup. It’s an exceptionally capable machine when it comes tackling terrain that would otherwise be deemed unridable. “Lumbering onward with determination” is how we described its trail manners in contrast with lighter, more agile fat bikes that lack the Ice Cream Truck’s stability and traction as well as its substantial heft.

surly-wednesday-steel-1455425961546-1arxp0nklaez9-1000-90-67b3454
#: #

The Wednesday is constructed from 4130 tubing, natch

The Wednesday is a very different machine. Yes, it’s still a heavy weight, at 35.2lb / 16kg, but it’s better suited to the type of riding the average rider is looking to do. Unlike the Ice Cream Truck, the Wednesday can’t run 5in tires on ultra-wide, 100mm rims. Tire clearance is limited to 26×3.8in tires with the axle in the forwardmost position. With the axle pushed back in the track ends, the Wednesday can fit 26×4.6in tires on rims up to 80mm wide — plenty of cushion for most snow or sand. 

Other key differences between the Wednesday and the Ice Cream Truck include the use of a slimmer 177x12mm thru-axle rear end and a narrower 100mm threaded bottom bracket shell, as opposed to the 132mm press-fit bottom bracket used on the Ice Cream Truck.

The narrower bottom bracket stance gives the Wednesday a noticeably narrower Q-factor. This is worth mentioning if you’ve encountered knee problems with fatter fat bikes.

Like its big brother, the Wednesday comes with a full complement of eyelets for racks and fenders and an impressive array of braze-ons for bottle cages and cargo carriers. The 4130 steel frame also features a port for an internally-routed dropper seatpost.

surly-wednesday-dropper-1455425606875-1deb6ala5so7j-1000-90-9e89062
#: #

The Wednesday’s dropper seatpost port

The Wednesday’s fit as well as it trail demeanor is akin to a modern trail bike, with a short rear end and longer front center. For the number crunchers, the Wednesday has relatively short, 17.1in / 435mm chainstays (in the forward position) and a rangy 27in / 687mm front center. The 17.2in/436mm reach numbers of the size Medium I tested would have pegged it as a large frame a few short years ago. But with stems getting shorter, it’s par for the course.

The 69-degree head angle isn’t as slack as most trail-oriented hardtails, but it keeps the front end nimble and the fat tires take care of the rest, obliterating most small to medium-sized obstacles just fine.

About 70% of my time aboard the Wednesday was spent on snowpacked singletrack. The stock 3.8in-wide tires don’t deliver the same bite in soft snow as wider tires, though they’re also more manageable when rallying the Wednesday on dirt. Self-steer, the bane of fat bike handling, was still present on hardpack, though less so than with the Ice Cream Truck. Tire squirm was less of an issue, too.

Cost-cutting critique

The Wednesday’s budget-friendly price means some corners had to be cut. In most cases Surly did a good job of balancing the price to performance ratio.

The SRAM X5 shifters and drivetrain may not be the lightest or offer the crispest shifting, but all the components proved reliable, and the Truvativ X5 double crankset with its 34/22t chainrings is a good match for the Wednesday.

surly-wednesday-shiftbrake-1455425877930-fmfjc51mdy81-1000-90-4b009e7
#: #

The SRAM X5 drivetrain works well, but the Tektro levers and Hayes brakes are a let down

The brakes, however, were a let down. Any rider accustomed to mid- or high-end hydraulic brakes will bemoan the lack of reach adjust in the Tektro 520 brake levers and be irritated by the on/off feel of Hayes’ mechanical MX Comp calipers.

Again, this is an affordable kit, not a no-expense-spared wünderbike. If the Wednesday were my personal fat bike, I’d swap the stock brakes for any level of SRAM’s current Guide series. They’ve got modulation in spades and perform well even in sub-zero conditions.

surly-wednesday-tire-1455425961547-1b6zy8e6oijrj-1000-90-9d0944e
#: #

Surly’s Nate tires have plenty of knobs, but the stiff casings hold the tire back

Fat bike tires can get quite expensive. Surly’s Nate tires are good, but stiff; the 27tpi version that come stock on the Wednesday doesn’t fully maximize the tread’s potential to garner grip. The wire bead also adds significant heft over the folding version. 

Verdict

surly-wednesday-full-3-1455426174695-1vtbabm1896tq-1000-90-6fac904
#: #

Despite price-point component complaints, the Wednesday is still a good value bike

The Wednesday is a good gateway to fat biking. Its trail manners make it fun to ride in any season and the well-built frame is worthy of upgrading as you go.  

Advertisement

My advice for riders considering the Wednesday: if the lack of modulation and reach adjust bother you as much as it did me, swap out the brakes as your budget permits. As for the low thread-count tires, ride them until they’re worn and replace them with tires of your choosing with supple casings.

Product Specifications

Product

Name Wednesday
Brand Surly

Available Colours Robbin's Egg Blue
Saddle Velo VL-2155, CroMoly rails
Wheelbase (in) 44.2
Top Tube (in) 24
Standover Height (in) 30.5
Seat Tube (in) 16.4
Chainstays (in) 17.1
Bottom Bracket Height (in) 12.5
Brake Levers Tektro 520
Weight (lb) 35.2
Chainring Size (No of Teeth) 22 34
Year 2016
Weight (kg) 16
Shifters SRAM X5
Seatpost Alloy 30.9 x 410mm
Seat Angle 73.5
Rims Surly My Other Brother Darryl, 80mm w/speedholes
Available Sizes XS S M L XL
Front Derailleur SRAM X5
Bottom Bracket SRAM GXP
Brakes Hayes MX Comp V-Series, 160mm rotors
Cassette Microshift H100, 11-36t, 10-speed
Chain KMC X10
Cranks Truvativ X5
Fork Surly chromoly fork, 150mm spacing, suspension corrected
Front Hub Formula 150 x 15mm thru-axle
Rear Tyre Surly Nate 26 x 3.8˝, 27tpi
Front Tyre Surly Nate 26 x 3.8˝, 27tpi
Handlebar Alloy flat bar, 750mm
Head Angle 69
Pedals N/A
Rear Derailleur SRAM X5
Rear Hub Formula 177 x 12mm thru-axle
Frame size tested M