Carrera Vanquish Disc review

Are disc brakes worth having at a discount?

Our rating 
3.0 out of 5 star rating 3.0
GBP £425.00 RRP

Our review

Getting discs for £425 is impressive but it comes at the cost of lively frame quality
Buy if, You want great all-weather control for round town missions
Pros: Disc brakes genuinely improve all-weather control, decent kit for the cash
Cons: Frame is lifeless on climbs and nervous on descents, limited tyre space, cheap bar tape
Skip to view product specifications


Halfords’ house brand Carrera is always a good place to look for a great ride if your wallet is on a short leash. Now, it has opened up the latest stopping trend to a whole new audience with the Vanquish Disc.

Advertisement

If you’re after all-weather control for day-to-day commuting rather than conquering epic climbs or rumbling down rough tracks, it’s well worth a look.

Seeing as disc brakes are the big sell I’ll cover them first. They are cable operated rather than hydraulic, but the cables are decent quality so they don’t feel too spongy. Cable operation also means you’ll have to compensate for pad wear by winding the inner pad plate inwards, hydraulic systems adjust automatically.

They also need to be set up carefully to stop them squealing loudly at first. Rim damage doesn’t matter, you won’t get debris in the pads and they’ll take standard Shimano pads as well as Tektro ones if you need spares.

The Shimano Claris here is the older version with external cables, but it still works okay
Philip Sowels / Immediate Media

Most importantly, having the pads working on a dry, clean rotor means far better bad weather control and power than wet rim brakes, particularly ones with moulded pads.

Carrera’s remarkable value reputation is reinforced by the fact that while the discs add £50 over the rim-braked Vanquish, general kit levels are still competitive.

In fact, the mix of old style Claris gears and shifters with smooth functioning but awkward looking side sprouting gear cables, driven by an FSA Tempo crank, is exactly the same as that on the £500 Raleigh Criterium.

Despite being heavier, the Carrera gets a harder bottom gear. The single-bolt saddle clamp also needs checking occasionally to stop it coming loose and it definitely deserves thicker bar tape to add some comfort. The Vanquish does get a colour-coded saddle and stem though and the Kenda tyres are decent quality.

That flexy frame feel means less punishment comes through to the rider
Russell Burton / Immediate Media

The carbon fork legs give a reasonable ride quality, which is lucky as there’s very little room in them to contemplate running a bigger tyre. Mudguard space is limited too, even though there are mudguard mounts high up inside the fork legs.

There’s a bit more space between the straight A-frame rear stays, but just because it has got disc brakes don’t assume that it’s ready to take on rough road ‘gravel’ adventures.

The frame is also the place where the cost compromises of the package become clear in ride terms. Super-narrow teardrop down-tube and top tube and a slim non-tapered head tube translate into obvious flex when you’re descending or turning hard. Together with the slim stays they suck power out of the Carrera on climbs too.

On a positive note, that flexy frame feel means less punishment comes through to the rider than normal on poor road surfaces. Bigger lumps still slap you about, and the cheap, thin handlebar tape really undermines hand comfort on longer rides.

Advertisement

While geometry of the 54cm version is relatively conventional for that size it’s only available in one other smaller 51cm option, which restricts its appeal.

Product Specifications

Product

Name Vanquish disc
Brand Carrera

Available Sizes 51cm 54cm
Rear Wheel Weight 2170
Frame size tested 54cm
Wheelbase (cm) 100
Top Tube (cm) 55
Seat Tube (cm) 47
Chainstays (cm) 42
Wheelset Carrera double-wall, KT alloy hubs
Weight (kg) 10.74
Trail 6
Stem Carrera
Shifters Shimano Claris 2x8
Seatpost Carrera
Seat Angle 74
Saddle Carrera
Rear Tyre Kenda K1018, 25mm
Bottom Bracket FSA cartridge
Rear Derailleur Shimano Claris
Headset Type FSA No.10
Head Angle 72.5
Handlebar Carrera
Front Wheel Weight 1730
Front Tyre Kenda K1018, 25mm
Front Derailleur Shimano Claris
Frame Material Triple-butted alloy
Fork Offset 4.5
Fork Carbon legs, straight alloy steerer
Cranks FSA Tempo 50/34
Chain KMC Z72
Cassette Shimano HG50 11-28
Brakes Tektro Md-c400 mechanical disc
All measurements for frame size tested 54cm