On-One Pickenflick SRAM CX1 review

Top value titanium 'crosser

Our rating 
4.5 out of 5 star rating 4.5
GBP £1,800.00 RRP | USD $2,472.00

Our review

An immensely enjoyable 'crosser that offers great value for money
Skip to view product specifications

On-One is a name well known to riders who dabble in cycling’s grimier disciplines – though most roadies will be more familiar with sister marque Planet X. The company’s cyclocross models are shared between the two brands, and the Pickenflick is a proper racer built around a titanium chassis.

Advertisement
  • Highs: Lively ride, great handling, impressive spec and weight for the money
  • Lows: Race focus limits versatility; slight front disc rub; an inline seatpost would be better
  • Buy if: You want a brilliant ‘cross racer that can turn it’s hand to other things

Being built for competition doesn’t mean leisure riders should ignore it though, because if there’s one thing we’ve learnt from the explosion in all-road bikes (or ‘gravel grinders‘, if you must), it’s that there are real benefits to be found in blurring the lines.

The Pickenflick’s 3Al/2.5V titanium frame is a stout thing with chunky stays and a tapered head tube that blends neatly with a butch looking full carbon fork. Cabling is external, and since it’s a ‘cross bike, the rear brake hose runs above the top tube to make shouldering easier.

1433846652361-1lhep58qmbtpy-1000-90-a429307
The pickenflick’s off-road handling is wonderfully capable:

The Pickenflick’s off-road handling is wonderfully capable

What really sets the Pickenflick apart is how it’s equipped. The keen eyed will note that the left brake lever is just that – there’s no shifter paddle, because there’s only one chainring up front and hence no front derailleur, giving 1×11-speed gearing.

Why? A ‘one-by’ arrangement simply has less to go wrong: with a clutch on the rear derailleur and ‘X-Sync’ chainring technology that uses tall, squared-off teeth in a narrow/wide alternating pattern, chain drops are a non-issue, and of course you’re relieved of front shifting duties too. All this will be old hat to mountain bikers, but it’s one of many technologies that’s proving useful away from the trails.

On-One is a mountain bike brand first and foremost though, and the Pickenflick’s slightly unconventional geometry seems to reflect this. In recent years those designing for the rough stuff have been exploring the handling advantages of ever-shorter stems and wider bars, with added top tube length to preserve the reach.

While our small Pickenflick had relatively standard 42cm bars, its 555mm top tube sounded on the face of it to be exceptionally long. In reality, with a fairly slack seat angle of 73 degrees and an 80mm stem, we didn’t feel at all stretched. We’d have preferred an inline seatpost though, as the laid back geometry had us sliding the saddle forward to its front limit.

The lack of inline post meant our saddle had to sit at its front limit
The lack of inline post meant our saddle had to sit at its front limit:
David Caudery

The lack of an inline post meant our saddle had to sit at its front limit

The front end is slacker than on most road bikes too, and the sum of all these details is a bike that rides brilliantly off the tarmac, with accurate yet forgiving handling at all speeds and whatever the incline. We took the Pickenflick to Salisbury Plain to try out some gravel, and it acquitted itself marvellously.

You might expect 35mm ‘cross tyres and a metal frame to feel heavy, but this is light for a disc bike – and it shows. It’s also impressively stiff under power, responding in a most satisfying manner to a good kick of the pedals. The big seat tube and 31.6mm post don’t offer a lot of give, but with decent volume tyres (and room to go bigger), comfort isn’t really a concern.

The SRAM hydraulic brakes bite less hard than their Shimano counterparts, but feel nice and progressive. Some front disc rub was evident out of the saddle, which we put down to a minute amount of flex in the fork.

The only catch to the Pickenflick is that it’s a very focused machine. Because at heart it’s a race bike, there’s no provision for everyday practicalities like mudguards, and while the 1×11 setup offers a decent range, it can feel slightly lacking on fast paved descents or prolonged steep climbs. There’s a cheaper version of the bike with standard gearing if you prefer though – and in any case, the Pickenflick is a tremendously capable ride that with a change of tyres could rival plenty of pure road machines.

Advertisement

On-One Bikes ships worldwide – for more info go to www.on-one.co.uk.

Product Specifications

Product

Name Pickenflick SRAM CX1 (15)
Brand On-One

Available Sizes S M L XL
Rear Wheel Weight 2180
Wheelbase (cm) 104
Top Tube (cm) 56
Standover Height (cm) 78.5
Seat Tube (cm) 53
Chainstays (cm) 43
Bottom Bracket Height (cm) 28.5
Wheelset Planet X Disc rims, QR hubs
Weight (kg) 9.16
Trail 9.8
Stem Planet X CNC, 80mm
Shifters SRAM Force CX1
Seatpost Carbon, 31.6mm
Seat Angle 74
Saddle Team Planet X
Rear Tyre Continental CycloXKing, 35mm
Bottom Bracket SRAM Force CX1 GXP
Rear Derailleur SRAM Force CX1
Headset Type FSA sealed cartridge
Head Angle 68
Handlebar Planet X Strada Compact, 420mm
Front Wheel Weight 1780
Front Tyre Continental CycloXKing, 35mm
Front Derailleur SRAM Force CX1
Frame Material 3Al/2.5V titanium
Fork Offset 4
Fork Carbon CX disc, carbon steerer
Cranks SRAM Force CX1, 42t, 172.5mm
Chain SRAM PC1170
Cassette SRAM Force CX1, 11-32
Brakes SRAM Force CX1
Frame size tested M