This prototype 1,290g carbon-spoked wheelset from Hunt features a totally new patented process for attaching spokes. That, along with a filament-wound carbon rim makes this an exciting new all-carbon wheelset.
Based on your comments, we got back to Hunt Wheels about some key points. This article was last updated on 23 November 2018 accordingly.
The use of a truly unique carbon spoke system is the headline news for this prototype wheelset — no other wheelset currently available uses the same technology.
In fact, not many wheelsets use carbon spokes at all, and if they do, they often come with significant restrictions.
Carbon spokes cannot be made in the same way as a regular steel one — it’s not possible to add threads to carbon fibre, so different ways of attaching them to both the hub and rim have to be designed.
Most of the carbon-spoked wheels that we know about actually bond the spokes to hub and rim, making the wheel a one-piece unit that isn’t serviceable. Two notable examples are Lightweight and Mavic Cosmic Ultimate wheels.
Mavic also offers its R-Sys wheelset, which uses replaceable carbon pillar spokes, though it appears to be the only wheelset of its kind. Additionally, the large diameter, hollow spokes present a significant aerodynamic obstacle to speedy airflow.
Indeed, while carbon spokes can offer competitive weights, they generally require more material to be used than would be needed for a steel spoke.
Carbon fibre has a higher strength to weight ratio than steel but it is also not particularly dense. This means more material volume is required than for steel in order to achieve the same strength (though that larger volume will still be lighter than the ‘equivalent strength’ steel).
Looks like a normal spoke, except it’s carbon Hunt
That means that carbon spokes often end up being ‘fatter’ than an equivalent steel spoke, resulting in an aerodynamic impediment.
In contrast, with these spokes, Hunt claims that there is no detrimental impact. In fact, it is still undertaking testing to figure out whether any aerodynamic advantage can be gained.
A new carbon spoke system
The spoke system that Hunt is using is different as it, on paper at least, combines the favourable properties of steel spokes with the weight saving of a carbon spoke.
Starting with weight, the new spoke and nipple weigh in at only 3.2g — that’s 1.35g lighter than the claimed weight for the class-leading Sapim CX-Ray (with an alloy nipple). For the 16 front and 21 rear spokes of the prototype wheelset that adds up to a weight saving just shy of 50g.
It’s not just the weight savings that are important here though. The carbon spokes provide both higher stiffness and better fatigue life in comparison to traditional steel spokes, despite the lower weight.
The hub mount is just a straight-pull interface Hunt
The carbon fibre is an unidirectional layup, giving the spoke a load limit of 300kgf. That far exceeds the 125kgf tension that carbon rims are usually built up with.
There are some unique things going on that allow the spoke to be mounted in a relatively ‘conventional’ way.
The spokes are designed to be used with a straight-pull hub. However, the mounting interface does not sit directly on the carbon fibre material.
Instead, the spoke is fitted with a flared aluminium cap at its base. Rather than being bonded — which would introduce a potential point of failure — this cap is mechanically fixed to the end of the spoke.
During forming, the alloy cap is placed on the spoke, and the carbon fibre head is flared and tapered. This in turn effectively wedges the cap in place when it is slid to the end of the spoke.
An alloy cap with threads is attached in the same way at the top of the spoke. While it looks like a conventional nipple, this is actually fixed in place — i.e. it can’t be turned to tighten or loosen the spoke.
This part looks like a traditional nipple, but it is actually bonded to the carbon spoke. This provides a seat to prevent the spoke twisting it when tightening from inside the rim bed Benedict Pfender / Immediate Media
Instead, the seats are used to hold the spoke in place and prevent rotation during truing. An internal nipple can be accessed from the rim bed and threads onto the cap, allowing the spoke to be tensioned.
While the mounting method is very similar to a traditional straight-pull spoke, the carbon spoke does require larger holes to be drilled in the rim making it incompatible with existing components.
Nonetheless, the maintenance of these spokes is the closest we have seen to any conventional wheel, and should significantly streamline servicing of such a wheelset. If indeed the spokes are as user-friendly as they seem, this could overcome one of the major limitations that has encumbered complete carbon wheels.
The supplier Hunt has partnered with for these wheels has patented this spoke production process. While we may see other wheels and manufacturers using this technology, Hunt hopes to be the first to offer a wheel with this system.
Filament wound rim
The spokes aren’t the only interesting thing going on here. Rather than use a conventional prepreg layup, Hunt is experimenting with filament winding for the new rims.
This process involves winding the carbon fibre filament around a mandrel into the desired shape, instead of building up the structure with pre-cut ‘sheets’ of carbon fibre.
This has a number of potential advantages. Because it’s largely computer controlled, filament winding can offer precise and repeatable carbon construction, without the variability associated with hand layup. The process could also help reduce manufacturing costs and help scale production.
The current prototype has a 38mm deep profile with an 18mm internal width
The precise nature of the computer controlled manufacturing results in a more consistent layup that allows a lower proportion of resin to be used (the component that actually binds the carbon fibres together), reducing weight for the same strength.
Filament winding also allows precise tailoring of the structure so that carbon fibres are oriented in the direction of load (the direction in which they are strongest), and can be wound to reinforce key areas and moreover (particularly helpful for reinforcing spoke holes, and the use of a continuous length of carbon filament) can all help improve strength and reduce weight, while making layups possible that couldn’t traditionally be achieved by hand.
Up until now, filament winding has generally been used for simpler geometries such as pressure vessels. However, advances in technology have made more complex shapes possible.
We’ve struggled to get our heads around how a rim would be manufactured, though we imagine that at a basic level a filament winding a rim would look something like this.
Brands such as Velocite, FSE and Lightweight also offer filament wound rims, but the technology isn’t widespread so far. It does however offer some compelling advantages, so it’s exciting to see another brand experimenting with this construction method.
We were unable to get many more details from Hunt about the rim. The current prototype has a 38mm deep profile with an 18mm internal width, but Hunt was understandably tight-lipped about anything else.
A completely new carbon wheel
As it stands, the current prototype wheelset weighs in at 573 grams for the 16-spoke, radially laced front wheel and 717 grams for the 2:1 ratio, two-cross laced, 21-spoke rear (1,290g for the math-allergic). This weight includes rim tape.
The complete wheelset weighs in at a sprightly 1,290 grams Benedict Pfender / Immediate Media
However, it should be noted that this wheel is still very much a prototype and various elements are subject to change and improvement. The wheelset we had a peek at is actually the only one even Hunt has at the moment
These prototypes have been built up as a proof of concept, in particular, to prove that the spokes provide a viable, reliable and workable option for a high-performance wheelset.
Hunt wheel availability
Hunt hopes to be the first to market with this new spoke technology and anticipates a launch in early 2019.
Pricing is yet to be announced but keep an eye out here as we’ll keep you updated as we find out more.