The best steel road bikes in 2020 | 5 timeless bikes that will never go out of fashion

The five best steel road bikes of 2020 as rated by the BikeRadar test team

  The products mentioned in this article are selected and reviewed independently by our journalists. When you buy through links on our site we may earn an affiliate commission, but this never influences our opinion.

Classic looks, a truly sublime ride quality and impressive longevity are among the many reasons why you may want to buy a steel road bike. 

Advertisement

There’s also no denying that these days, a skinny steel road-going bike stands out among a crowd of chunky-tubed aluminium and carbon bikes. For some, this will be rationale enough. 

Whatever motive has drawn you to the idea of adopting the chromo life, these are the five best steel road bikes of 2020 as ridden, tested and rated by BikeRadar

We have even more steel road bike reviews lined up for later this year so watch this space for updates to this list very, very soon.

The best steel road bikes in 2020

  • All-City Macho Man: £1,649
  • All-City Mr Pink: £1,900
  • Genesis Equilibrium: £1,099
  • Ricthey Road Logic: £2,100 / $1,760
  • The Light Blue Wolfson: £2,100

All-City Macho Man

4.0 out of 5 star rating
Best steel road bikes
The details on the Macho Man’s frame shine out.
Robert Smith Photography / Immediate Media
  • £1,649 (international pricing for our test bike build is N/A)
  • All-road versatility makes it an ideal do-it-all bike
  • Super comfortable ride quality

The All-City Macho man is more ’cross-like in its leanings, with a relatively high bottom bracket clearance for tyres up to 38mm wide.

That said, All-City pitches the Macho Man as a bike that “functions as an everyday mount that you use for ripping trails, bombing alleys, commuting, riding in the wet and generally getting rad”, and that matches our findings.

If you fit a set of slicks and drop the front end a bit, this could be a great road wagon. Better still, a full complement of mudguard mounts also mean this could be a great option for year-round commuting. 

Our review relates to the UK-spec bike as built by ISON, but the overall package is similar to the complete bike sold in the US and elsewhere. 

All-City Mr Pink

4.0 out of 5 star rating
Best steel road bikes
This is a bike that’s absolutely full of character.
Robert Smith
  • £1,900 (international pricing for our test bike build is N/A)
  • Classic geometry on a beautifully-finished frame
  • Generous mudguard and tyre clearances for a rim brake bike on the Mr Pink Classic

The Mr Pink is one of the most long-standing bikes in All-City’s lineup. 

The bike has fairly traditional road geometry which results in a snappy handling bike that is matched with a super-smooth ride quality that’s typical of skinny steel. 

Two versions of the Mr Pink are available – the regular Mr Pink and the Mr Pink Classic. The latter comes with a steel fork and also adds the provision to fit mudguards up front. 

Like the Macho Man, we tested the UK build, but the international build is broadly similar. 

Genesis Equilibrium

4.0 out of 5 star rating
Best steel bikes
We love the look of the silver 105 groupset on the Equilibrium.
Courtesy
  • £1,099 (international pricing N/A)
  • Super smooth, silent and superbly supple ride
  • Rarely-seen silver version of 105 R7000 groupset adds a touch of class

The Genesis Equilibrium is available in a number of different guises, spanning steel disc endurance bikes to more traditional rim-braked audax-wagons as reviewed here. 

The bike has clearances for 28mm tyres and will gladly take mudguards front and rear. 

The bike is outfitted with a rarely-seen silver version of Shimano’s 105 R7000 groupset. This handsome group nicely complements the snazzy blue finish of the frameset. 

An upgrade from the stock Promax brakes would really take this bike to the next level but, that aside, the Equilibrium is very unlikely to leave you disappointed. 

Ritchey Road Logic

4.0 out of 5 star rating
Best steel bikes
The Ritchey Road Logic has been around for donkey’s years.
Robert Smith / Immediate Media
  • £2,100 / $1,760 / AU$N/A
  • Beautifully-finished, classy looking steel frameset
  • Confident and smooth handling

The Road Logic has been in Ritchey’s lineup for a long time. It has evolved over time, but it has settled into its role as a do-it-all TIG-welded steel road wagon.

The frame is beautifully finished with exceptionally neat welds and a lovely deep-blue finish.

We reviewed the bike as a complete build, which was briefly offered by Ritchey in 2018. The bike is once again available frame-only, but our assessments of the ride quality – which were very positive – remain. 

The Light Blue Wolfson

4.0 out of 5 star rating
Best steel bikes
The Wolfson is simply a great steel bike.
David Caudery / Immediate Media
  • £2,100, international pricing N/A
  • Excellent and pleasingly springy signature steel ride quality
  • Good value for money for the build

The Light Blue is an in-house brand of aforementioned UK distributor ISON – which also distributes All-City and Surly. 

The Wolfson is Light Blue’s do-it-all steel road platform. The Reynolds 853 tubeset offers a pleasingly comfortable and lively ride quality that is matched with a, for the money, decent build kit. 

The brakes would benefit from an upgrade to nicer pads but, beyond that, the Wolfson will not leave you wanting. 

Steel road bike buyer’s guide

Frame geometry

The geometry of a road bike is the biggest determiner for how a bike will handle. 

Generally speaking, road bikes can be split into two categories: race and endurance. 

In brief, race bikes will have a lower more aggressive riding position matched with steeper head and seat tube angles, a shorter wheelbase and longer reach, resulting in quicker handling. 

Endurance bikes prioritise comfort and stability with a longer wheelbase and more mellow handling.

The majority of modern steel road bikes sit in the latter camp (though there are, of course, exceptions). The compliant and comfortable nature of a steel frame also lends itself well to this role. 

Versatility

All-City Mr Pink with Velo Orange mudguards
On the right bike, mudguards can even complement the look of a bike.
Jack Luke / Immediate Media

As steel bikes often err towards the endurance side of things, you’ll often find provision to fit mudguards and racks, as well as generous tyres clearances. This gives them a level of versatility that isn’t often found on aluminium or carbon bikes. 

Tradition and physical constraints also mean that steel road bikes typically use the most unfussy of standards – threaded bottom brackets, external cables and external headsets make sourcing replacement parts and maintenance a breeze

Longevity

In the event of a frame failure, steel bikes are far, far easier to repair than other materials such as titanium, carbon or aluminium. 

It’s possible to go as far as replacing entire tubes, but that may not be economical in many cases.

However, for small repairs, you may be surprised by how affordable the prices your friendly local frame builder will charge. 

Double-butt-what-now?

Manufacturers will often quote the steel that is used to construct its frames.

More expensive tubesets will see increasingly exotic tube shapes used to tune ride quality, ultra thin-walled tubing – which reduces weight and can result in a lively ride – and double- or even triple-butted forming. 

Big names in the tubing industry include Reynolds, Tange, Columbus and Dedacciai. It’s also increasingly common to see brands speccing their own ‘custom-drawn’ tubing. 

The difference in ride quality between bog-standard straight un-butted ‘gas pipe’ tubing and high-end ultra-thin walled tubing is fairly chasmic. However, everything in the middle-range is much of a muchness. Geometry and tyre choice will have a far greater impact on how a steel road bike rides than tube choice here. 

Advertisement

That said, there is no denying that the ride quality of truly skinny steel can be absolutely sublime, with a zingy spring that is quite unlike anything else.