Pedals have a difficult job. For starters, they’re one of the three contact points where your body and your bike meet, so have to provide a suitable interface as well as an element of control.
They’re a crucial part of any bike, but they come in a wide variety of shapes, sizes and styles. And as far as choosing a mountain bike pedal is concerned, the most important decision you need to make is whether you want flats or clipless. Our best mountain bike pedals list should help you to decide.
Flat or clipless pedals?
This buyer’s guide contains our pick of the best flat and clipless mountain bike pedals. Use the links below to jump straight to the relevant section.
Flat mountain bike pedals
Flat pedals are essentially just a platform for each foot. They’re double-sided, so it doesn’t matter which way up they are and there’s usually some extra grip provided by strategically placed pins.
The bigger the pedal’s face or platform, the greater the area you have to plant your foot and the greater the contact between you and your bike.
Flat pedals let you move your feet about as you please and are preferred by some riders on technical terrain as a result.
Clipless mountain bike pedals
Clipless or SPD pedals, on the other hand, are a bit of a misnomer since they clip onto special cleats mounted on the soles of your shoes.
The confusion with the name boils down to the fact that when this sort of pedal first appeared, its main selling point was how it enabled riders to discard the uncomfortable toeclips and straps they’d been using up until then.
Clipless mountain bike pedals are also double-sided, unlike road-specific clipless pedals, and since they rely on a mechanical attachment, rather than the surface area and pins to keep rider and bike connected, they’re typically a lot smaller than flats.
But don’t worry if you can’t decide one way or another because ‘trail’ pedals provide a halfway house between clipless and platform models. They marry a mechanical cleat-attachment device with a large pedal body for a ‘best of both worlds’ option.
The best mountain bike pedals in 2020
Best flat MTB pedals, as rated by our expert testers
- HT PA03A: £35 / $69
- Nukeproof Horizon Pro Sam Hill Enduro: £89.99
- Burgtec Penthouse Flat MK5: £110
- DMR Vault Brendog Ice: £110
- Burgtec MK4 Composite: £40
- Deity TMAC: $168.99
- Gusset S2: £80
- HT Supreme ANS10: £79.99
- Pedaling Innovations Catalyst: £79.99
- Superstar Nano-x EVO: £49.99
- £35 / $69
- Large platform with plenty of grip
- Lightweight nylon bodies
- A very nice price
These curiously named little pedals are some of the best we’ve ever tested.
Contrary to the popular quote, these are genuinely light, cheap and strong. They’re only a little bit smaller than some of the largest flat pedal designs on the market yet weigh just 349g for a pair.
The unusually flat pedal bodies are made from nylon rather than alloy and feature enough cut-outs to shed the worst of mud. Ten aggressive pins per side mean that we had no grip issues regardless of shoe choice and conditions.
The only real bad thing we have to say about these is that they tend to look scruffy before other pedals do – but that’s really being picky.
Nukeproof Horizon Pro Sam Hill Enduro
- Excellent shape
- Enduro World Series winning flats
- 10 pins per side offer great grip
These pedals and their earlier incarnations have won at the highest level under the feet of chief test pilot and three-time Enduro World Series champ Sam Hill.
The Horizons have a perfectly-sized body that strikes an inimitable balance between grip, support and size.
With 10 pins per side and a concave shape, the pedals are a top performer. The pins can be adjusted from 5mm to 6mm by removing the supplied shims using a 2.5mm Allen key.
Two sealed bearings and two DU bushes keep the pedals spinning, and while they’re ultimately not the most durable solution, they’re cheap and easy to replace.
Nukeproof sells all the spares you’ll need to rebuild them when the time comes.
Latest deals for the Nukeproof Horizon Pro Sam Hill
Burgtec Penthouse Flat Mk5
- Built to last
- Slim, concave platform
- Plenty of colour options
It’s now been 17 years since Burgtec’s original Penthouse Flat pedals emerged. Since then, the British-made parts have evolved with the sport itself. This latest incarnation, the Mk5, is pretty close to being the perfect flat mountain bike pedal.
The large platform isn’t big enough to become a real hazard through rock gardens, but there’s plenty of grip thanks to generous concavity and eight 4.5mm tall removable pins. They’re available in lots of different colour options to match or contrast with your bike.
A pair with steel axles weighs 382g, which is fairly light for alloy pedals.
DMR Vault Brendog Ice
- Offset platform makes pin removal easy
- Chamfered edges deflect ground strikes
- 11 perfectly-placed pins
The totally concave platform and 11 well-placed pins make the Vault a BikeRadar staff favourite, and they do a fantastic job of keeping your foot in place.
The pins can be changed or removed from the underside of the pedal, which means that damage won’t hamper removal and the pedals’ angled edges help to deflect them over rocks and ruts.
The Brendog edition comes with sharper pins than the standard ones, dubbed Moto pins, but they weren’t as grippy as DMR’s standard offering.
There’s also a halo edition, which has a super-lightweight body, but it’s pretty expensive at £220.
Latest deals for the DMR Vault Brendog Ice
Burgtec MK4 Composite flat pedals
- Good platform shape
- Removable pins
Identical in shape to the Penthouse MK4 pedals, the nylon/fibreglass body is concave and shares the same pin arrangement to their more expensive counterpart, but the pins aren’t quite as long.
At 375g they’re a full 71g lighter than the metal versions and we think the composite body means they’re more likely to brush over obstacles if you manage to strike the floor.
- Large pedal platform
- 14 pedal pins
- Robust construction
Freeride superstar Tyler McCaul’s signature pedals feature a large platform area, 14 pins located around the pedal’s peripheries and three bearings coupled with a DU bush to keep them spinning smoothly.
The large platform means they’re fairly susceptible to strikes from rocks, but they’re robust enough to keep any damage at bay.
The pins are screwed in from the pedal’s platform, which means that if you’ve hit them and damaged the pins you’ll need to find an alternative way of removing them from the pedal body.
At $168.99, these are some of the priciest pedals around at the moment, but they’re worth it for the performance they offer.
Gusset S2 flat pedals
- Concave profile
- Fantastic grip
- Removable 10mm pins
Developed with help from Red Bull athlete Matt Jones, the S2 is a top-performing pedal. The large metal platform has tapered edges to help glance-off rock strikes. The pedals are quite deep but this does mean they are particularly concave.
The removable 10mm pins offer plenty of grip, but the Allen heads get filled with mud, so replacing them can be a pain. The axles run on DU bushings and bearings so should stand the test of time.
HT Supreme ANS10
- Concave platform
- Removable and adjustable pins
- Very light at 376g a pair
These pedals are designed with extremely angled edges and a noticeably concave shape.
The hexagonal design helps to brush off rock and floor strikes with ease and keep your foot planted in rough terrain. The sharp pins contribute to making these exceptionally grippy.
The pins’ length is adjustable by 1mm, from 5mm to 6mm, and the 12mm axle length puts your feet in a comfortably wide position. At 376g, these pedals are some of the lightest out there.
Latest deals for the HT Supreme ANS10
Pedaling Innovations Catalyst
- Biggest rectangular platform around
- 30-day satisfaction guarantee
- Not refined, but good performance
The large rectangular 95 x 128mm platform can raise eyebrows, but Pedaling Innovations claims that the large platform will support your whole foot, helping with control and pedalling power input.
The impressive levels of grip and stability of these pedals dispelled any doubts we had about the design and meant the pedals inspired confidence on the trail.
The pedal has enough space for 14 pins, which can be configured in a combination of long and short to suit your needs. Unfortunately, the pins can only be tightened from the platform side, which does mean that if they get damaged they’re hard to replace.
Pedaling Innovations is so confident about the design that it offers a 30-day money back guarantee if you don’t like them.
Superstar Nano-x EVO
- Designed and made in the UK
- Well priced
- Pins are easy to replace
With a relatively large platform and plenty of replacement pins supplied in the box, these pedals represent great value for money and are manufactured in the UK.
Thanks to the offset design, the pins are easy to replace from underneath the pedal platform using a 3mm Allen key. The angled edges also deflect rocks well.
Best clipless MTB pedals, as rated by our expert testers
- Funn Ripper: £115
- Shimano PD-M520: £36.99 / $34.90
- Crankbrothers Mallet E LS: £149.99
- Shimano PD-M530: £39.99 / $39.99
- Shimano XT M8020 Trail: £90 / $120 / AU$158.95
- Shimano XT M8120 Trail: £100
- DMR V-Twin: £129.99
- Nukeproof Horizon CS: £100
- Time ATAC XC 6: £90
- Large platform
- Easy to clip in
- Smooth-running axles
With a wide platform and flat-pedal-like shape, these were an instant hit with our testers. The four pins positioned on each corner of the pedal mean you’ve got plenty of anti-twist grip, but they don’t bite in so hard that it’s difficult to clip out.
The concave platform means that they work well with downhill shoes. The tension-adjustable clip system is compatible with Shimano’s SPD system and the bush and bearing spun axles have proven to last the test of time.
- £36.99 / $34.90
- Excellent value for money
- Straightforward adjustability
- Reliable and simple to maintain
One of the most popular mountain bike pedals out there due to their simplicity and reliability.
Double-sided entry makes them easy to use, and therefore also very popular with commuters as well as mountain bikers.
While the RRP is around £36.99, they are frequently found online with prices as low as £20 – not to be sniffed at!
The PD-M520 uses the same mechanism as the more expensive XT and XTR versions, but down-specced to reach the lower price point. However, if well maintained and well lubricated, they are hard to distinguish from either of the pricier versions on the trail.
Simple cup and cone bearings make maintenance easy and quick.
Latest deals for the Shimano PD-M520
Crankbrothers Mallet E LS
- Best suited to DH-style shoes
- Concave, low profile cage
- Tunable fit
If money’s no object and you’re looking for a high performing trail, enduro or downhill pedal, the Mallet is a great option, especially when used with DH-style shoes.
The low-profile cage is concave, giving solid engagement between the shoes and the six pins located on the pedal’s body.
With changeable ‘traction pads’ and cleat shims, you can fine-tune the fit to suit different types of shoe.
On the trail, the pedal’s body offers flat pedal support with the added security of being clipped in, so you can focus on riding fast.
Latest deals for the Crankbrothers Mallet E LS
- £39.99 / $39.99
- Popular for a very good reason
- Simple to maintain
- Rugged and durable construction
If you prefer your SPDs with a cage, then Shimano’s M530s are not to be ignored – in fact, we’d consider them a modern classic. The cage doesn’t offer the same level of support as some competitors, but there’s still enough side support for most trail shoes.
They’re also cheap and – thanks to their simple cup and cone bearings – will last you for years. When they do eventually get tired you’ll be able to easily service them at home too.
If weight bothers you (these are 446g for a pair) then you may be better off with the XTs that feature below, but the M530 tends to keep most trail riders perfectly happy.
Latest deals for the Shimano PD-M530
Shimano XT M8020 Trail
- £90 / $120 / AU$158.95
- Great all-rounder
- Secure and familiar cleat and clip mechanism
- Slight increase in contact area for your foot
Designed for trail, all-mountain and enduro riders, Shimano’s XT Trail pedal encases the SPD mechanism within an alloy platform.
The new M8020 is 3.3mm wider than its predecessor, resulting in a claimed 11.7 per cent increase in contact surface. Additionally, the pedal body is now 0.5mm shallower, getting you a hair closer to the axle.
The pedals weighed 402g on our scales (408g claimed) and Shimano’s traditional steel cleat and clip mechanism means engaging and disengaging retains its familiar consistency (spring tension is easily adjusted with a 3mm Allen key).
The additional pedal-to-shoe contact surface of the Trails is subtle, but the extra width does help to prevent foot roll when tilting the bike into corners.
Latest deals for the Shimano XT M8020 Trail
Shimano XT M8210 Trail
- Great stability
- Good mud clearance
- Possibly incompatible with some shoes
The Shimano XT M8120 pedals are true fit-and-forget performers, requiring little to no maintenance and offering great resistance against tough, muddy conditions thanks to a large platform and easy to set up but clear positioning.
Cleat engagement was consistently snappy and the cage provided plenty of support only interfering with the bulkiest of XC shoes.
- Flat-pedal-like support and lateral grip
- Super-grippy pins
- Easy to clip into
The V-Twins come supplied with a variety of pins so that you can fine-tune the pedal’s feel.
Wearing skate-style DH shoes, the pedals provided plenty of grip and support when set up with all of the extra pins.
The SPD mechanism makes clipping in easy, but because of the high levels of grip on offer, getting unclipped can be more troublesome. But that’s a nice problem to have, right?
Latest deals for the DMR V-Twin
Nukeproof Horizon CS
- Four removable pins
- SPD-compatible mechanism
- Seriously grippy
With four removable pins per side, which extend up to 4mm above the wide platform, the Horizon is an incredibly grippy pedal.
The pins can be shortened if required, using washers, but the overall feel is akin to that given by a flat pedal.
The SPD-compatible mechanism means you can clip in forwards, backwards or from above. They’re supplied with 4-degree float cleats but a bigger 8-degree float cleat is available. If you want a bigger platform, Nukeproof’s CL version could be for you.
Latest deals for the Nukeproof Horizon CS
Time ATAC XC 6
- Plenty of float
- Easy entry
- Can be tricky to clip in
Thanks to Time’s cleat design, the ATAC XC 6 pedals have plenty of float, which can help reduce knee pain and improve your bike handling. If you’re more used to Shimano’s SPD system, the amount of movement can be unnerving at first, though.
They stand up to abuse in bad weather and we never had problems clipping in or out when they were covered in mud or even snow and ice. If you’re not careful, though, when you’re clipping in the pedal can roll forward, caused by their cageless design.
If this is a problem for you, the Time Speciale version with a cage might be for you.
They’ve proven to be very reliable during our testing period, brushing off knocks and continued use in bad weather.